Pro-Impeachment Camp Moves Closer to Victory in Brazil

April 17, 2016 Updated: April 18, 2016

BRASILIA, Brazil—Brazilian legislators pushing to oust President Dilma Rousseff appeared to have the upper hand Sunday night, with a wide margin voting to impeach her and cut short a term running through 2018.

More than two hours into voting, the pro-impeachment camp was leading 254 to 87. If 342 of the Chamber of Deputies’ 513 members vote in favor, the proceedings move to the Senate for a possible trial. If senators voted to hold a trial that would suspend Rousseff and hand over the top job to Vice President Michel Temer.

A close ally of the president lamented that many of her colleagues had “betrayed” Rousseff.

“It was a herd effect, and many (legislators) betrayed us. It was a double defeat,” said Brazilian Community Party legislator Orlando Silva, a close supporter of Rousseff.

Demonstrators demand the impeachment of Brazil's President Dilma Rousseff during a march next to large inflatable dolls of former President Luiz Inacio 'Lula' da Silva in prison garb and President Rousseff wearing a presidential sash with "Mother of Big Oil" written on it in Portuguese, in a reference to the corruption scandal involving Brazilian oil giant Petrobras, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on April 17, 2016. A vote Sunday in the lower house will determine whether the impeachment proceeds against President Rousseff. (AP Photo/Andre Penner)
Demonstrators demand the impeachment of Brazil’s President Dilma Rousseff during a march next to large inflatable dolls of former President Luiz Inacio ‘Lula’ da Silva in prison garb and President Rousseff wearing a presidential sash with “Mother of Big Oil” written on it in Portuguese, in a reference to the corruption scandal involving Brazilian oil giant Petrobras, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on April 17, 2016. A vote Sunday in the lower house will determine whether the impeachment proceeds against President Rousseff. (AP Photo/Andre Penner)

After more than 40 hours of debate that began Friday, legislators in Congress’ lower house began voting one by one Sunday evening, the culmination of months of political wrangling that exposed deep polarization in Latin America’s largest nation and most powerful economy.

Eduardo Cunha, the house speaker leading the impeachment push, called deputies individually, giving them time to speak before casting their vote. After each vote, both cheers and boos erupted while legislators looked up at a board keeping score.

Luiz Carlos Hauly, a deputy in the Social Democratic Party, the main opposition party, said Rousseff had to go.

“In Europe they change their government when it doesn’t have the majority,” he said. “This administration has no majority. It doesn’t have the means to govern.”

Simone Morgado, a member of the centrist Brazilian Democratic Movement, said impeachment proponents were trying to derail a democratically elected president.

“Given that Dilma didn’t commit any crime, like so many others in this chamber, which has no shame, I’m voting ‘no!’,” she said.

The extraordinary session came as the government is paralyzed and the population sharply divided, with friends and foes of Rousseff dismissing each other as “putchists” and “thieves.”

Outside the legislature, waves of pro- and anti-impeachment demonstrators flooded into the capital of Brasilia from across the huge nation. A metal wall more than a kilometer (mile) long was installed to keep the rival sides safely apart.

People on both sides watched the score on large movie screens, cheering or booing in accordance with their political leanings.

Patricia Santos, a retired 52-year-old schoolteacher outside Congress, said she was fed up with the status quo and wanted Rousseff out.

“We want our politicians to be less corrupt, so we hope impeaching her will send a signal to them all,” Santos said. “We know that all the parties are involved in the corruption but the (governing) Workers’ Party has been the leaders of this all for the last 13 years so they have to go.”

Thousands joined in demonstrations, both for and against the government, in other cities.

On Copacabana Beach in Rio de Janeiro, thousands of government supporters rallied as funk music blasted from a truck with large speakers.

Jader Alves, a 67-year-old retiree, promised that if Rousseff was impeached he would be back on the streets.

“My president was elected in 2014 and she will remain in office until 2018, no matter what,” said Alves.

In speeches by the leaders of the 25 parties in the Chamber of Deputies that preceded Sunday’s vote, lawmakers either embraced the impeachment as marking a much-needed clean slate for Brazil or slammed it as an illegal usurpation of power.

“Brazil is submerged in grave political, ethical, social crises,” said Fernando Coelho Filho, a representative from the northeastern state of Pernambuco. “. I have a lot of respect for the president, but she has lost authority and the credibility to lead even a minimum effort to get the country out of this situation.”

Daniel Almeida, a representative from Bahia state, agreed the country is mired in multiple crises, but insisted impeachment offered no solution.

“Through an illegitimate government, with no votes? That’s the way out?” he asked his fellow lawmakers.

Brazil’s president faced impeachment over allegations she broke fiscal laws. Her detractors describe the sleight-of hand accounting as a bid to boost her government’s floundering popularity amid a tanking economy and a corruption scandal so widespread it has taken down top public figures from across the political spectrum as well as some of the country’s richest businessmen.

Rousseff denied wrongdoing, pointing out that previous presidents used similar accounting techniques. The allegations, she insisted, were part of a “coup” spearheaded by Brazil’s traditional ruling elite to snatch power back from her left-leaning Workers’ Party, which has governed the past 13 years.

Brazil is grappling with problems on multiple fronts. The economy is contracting, inflation is around 10 percent and an outbreak of the Zika virus, which can cause devastating birth defects, has ravaged parts of northeastern states. Rio de Janeiro is gearing up to host the Olympics in August, but sharp budget cuts have fueled worries about whether the country will be ready.

Many of the people pushing to oust Rousseff face serious allegations of wrongdoing themselves. About 60 percent of the 594 members of Congress are facing corruption and other charges.

Temer, a 75-year-old with the Brazilian Democratic Movement, a party bereft of any concrete ideology that has a reputation for backroom wheeling and dealing, has tried to cast himself as a statesman above the fray and a unifying force that can heal a scarred nation.

However, he has been linked to the corruption scheme centered at the state-run Petrobras oil company. Also, because he signed off on some of the administration’s questioned accounting maneuvers, Temer could later potentially face impeachment proceedings.

The second in line to replace Rousseff is Cunha, the house speaker and long-time Rousseff enemy. He is facing money laundering and other charges for allegedly accepting some $5 million in kickbacks in connection with the Petrobras scheme and could also be stripped of office over allegations he lied when he told a congressional committee he didn’t hold any foreign bank accounts. Documents later emerged linking him and his family to Swiss bank accounts.

Under the special legal status afforded to Brazilian legislators and other top politicians, they must be tried by the Supreme Court, largely shielding them from prosecutions.

Rousseff trumpeted the corruption allegations dogging her enemies, insisting she was the only one not besmirched by corruption.

RECOMMENDED
TOP VIDEOS