Viewpoints
Opinion

Why ‘Proportionality’ Claims Are Bogus When It Comes to Israel’s Targeting of Hamas and Hezbollah

Why ‘Proportionality’ Claims Are Bogus When It Comes to Israel’s Targeting of Hamas and Hezbollah
Smoke rises from the site of an Israeli airstrike that targeted the southern Lebanese village of Khiam on Oct. 13, 2024, amid the continuing war between Hezbollah and Israel. AFP via Getty Images
|Updated:
Commentary

One of the favourite words used by critics of Israel in its current wars against Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon is “proportionality.’’ What is meant by this word is that there is no comparison between the civilian casualties in Gaza and Lebanon and those suffered by Israel on Oct. 7, 2023 (and after), and thus that Israel is guilty of breaking some sort of international norm in its defensive war against those two terrorist groups. The implication is that so many Palestinian civilians have been killed compared to Israelis that the numbers show proof positive that Israel is committing war crimes at best, genocide at worst.

David J. Bercuson
David J. Bercuson
Author
Professor David Bercuson is a senior fellow at the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy and director emeritus of the Centre for Military, Security, and Strategic Studies at the University of Calgary.