Political Instability Awaits the CCP

Political Instability Awaits the CCP
Chinese Communist Party’s head Xi Jinping (center) and lawmakers stand for the anthem during the closing session of the rubber-stamp legislature’s conference at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on March 11, 2021. (Kevin Frayer/Getty Images)
Ching Cheong

In 2022, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) will be plagued with internal political instability as its leader, Xi Jinping, tries to secure a third—if not lifelong—term at the 20th Party Congress this fall.

Such a move violates the CCP’s tradition of upholding the two-term limit (each lasting for five years) of the presidency, which was stipulated in Article 79 of the 1982 version of the Chinese constitution. In 2018, however, Xi amended the constitution to delete this clause, which removed the legal barrier to his bid for perpetual power. Naturally, Xi is sure to meet stiff resistance from various quarters within the Party.

Several events suggest that 2022 is likely to be a turbulent one for Xi and the CCP.

The first such event is the mysterious absence of Xi's right-hand man, Li Zhanshu, at a tea gathering on New Year's Eve, a traditional occasion in which members of the country's top leadership showcase their solidarity. Although Li reappeared on Jan. 11, proving that he's politically safe, his absence still caused speculation that Xi is facing strong opposition.

Li ranks third in the seven-member Politburo Standing Committee, the supreme governing body in China. As chairman of the National People’s Congress (NPC), China's rubber-stamp legislature, he was instrumental in amending the Chinese constitution to delete Article 79, the clause that set the presidential term limit to two.

Li’s absence wasn't caused by illness. Under normal circumstances, when a senior official is unable to attend an important meeting because of an illness, a communique stating that he applied for sick leave is released so that the absence doesn't lead to speculation. However, there was no such announcement on Li's absence.

Li’s absence could be the result of the anti-Xi faction trying to dislodge him, since he was the chief lawmaker who helped paved the way for Xi to retain power. Pressure against Li could have grown to the extent that Xi had to make some sort of compromise, leading to Li's temporary absence. This is a plausible explanation since during Li's absence, there was an article from China's top watchdog, the Central Disciplinary Commission (CDC), pointing obliquely at him when it mentioned that “a former leader of the Guizhou Province” had helped one of his family members subdue a business rival.

Li's reappearance on Jan. 11, sitting right next to Xi during a high-level meeting, suggests that the latter had somehow overcome pressure to unseat his protégé.

Another anomaly was the recall of Wang Shaojun from retirement to serve as chief of the Central Security Bureau (CSB), his previous post. The CSB is responsible for guarding all of the senior members of the Party and, therefore, its head must be someone who Xi totally trusts. At the same time, anyone trying to stage a coup d’etat has to rely on the CSB, just like what happened in 1976 when the so-called Gang of Four was arrested. Wang had already retired in 2019, but his reappearance at a Jan. 11 conference of senior leaders suggests that he was reinstalled as chief of the bureau.

When Wang retired in 2019, Zhou Hongxu, deputy chief of staff of the Northern Theater Army, took over as CSB director. By tradition, this post was usually taken up by people from within the bureau. The only exception was in 1963, when CCP founder Mao Zedong ordered a field army general to head the CSB after he was forced to claim responsibility for his failed policy in 1962, the Great Leap Forward, leading to mass deaths from starvation. The move showed that Mao was afraid of being dethroned after he was forced to recede from the forefront of the political stage.

Thus, when Xi ordered a field army general to head the CSB, it showed that he didn't trust the bureau. However, after a short while, the former CSB chief was recalled from retirement to head the same bureau again. Wang, 67, is obviously past the retirement age of 60. Xi's decision puzzled everyone and indicated that there's some sort of uncertainty at the core of the CCP.

Then came the indictment of former public security chief Sun Lijun on Jan. 13. One of the three charges against him was “illegal possession of a firearm.” As the deputy head of the police, possession of a gun isn't illegal, except in some very specific circumstances, such as in highly confidential senior conferences or in very close proximity to top leaders. In such situations, gun possession has to be pre-approved. Thus, charging a police head with illegal possession of a gun suggests that Sun could be suspected of trying to make an attempt on Xi’s life.

Sun owed his political rise to former CCP leader Jiang Zemin. Sun was the deputy director of the notorious “610 Office,” a Gestapo-like agency under the Public Security Ministry that was created for persecuting the spiritual group Falun Gong. He was promoted to deputy-ministerial rank when Zhou Yongkang, a powerful member of the CCP’s Politburo Standing Committee (the top decision-making body), was secretary of the CCP’s Central Political and Legal Affairs, which controls the country’s police, procuratorate, and court systems. Shortly after Xi gained power, Zhou was sentenced to life in prison for his alleged attempt to stage a coup d’etat against Xi. This close connection with Jiang and Zhou made Sun an obvious target of Xi.

 Five sacked "610 Office" directors/deputy directors. (The Epoch Times)
Five sacked "610 Office" directors/deputy directors. (The Epoch Times)

This is highly plausible when one takes into consideration that the communique issued by the CDC on Sun’s arrest on Sept. 30, 2021, enumerates his crimes such as the following:

Betraying the “two safeguards” and disregarding the “four awarenesses.” The “two safeguards” refer to safeguarding Xi’s position as the core leader of the CCP and safeguarding the centralized authority of the Party. The “four awarenesses” refer to political awareness (which means putting politics above all things else), awareness of the overall situation, awareness of Xi as the core of the Party, and awareness of the need to align oneself with Xi. These are the political slogans put forward by Xi as the standard for loyalty among CCP cadres. In the specific CCP lexicon, Sun’s political crime was his disloyalty to Xi.

Seriously endangering political security and seriously undermining the unity of the Party. In the CCP context, this could mean an attempted coup d'état.

Manipulating power to achieve personal political gain, including engaging in factional politics.

If the CDC found Sun guilty of these political crimes, then his “illegal possession of a firearm” suggests that he might have tried to assassinate Xi. In this regard, it's noteworthy that the CDC admitted publicly that there was a plot against Xi. On Sept. 13, 2021, two major media outlets in China published the same article that recapped a CDC “morning brief,” which disclosed that a “sinister gang” within the Public Security Bureau tried to make an attempt on Xi’s life.

It's no wonder that in his "2022 No. 1 Command for the Military Forces," a decree issued by Xi in his capacity as the supreme head of the military, he urged the military to prepare for a successful convening of the Party’s 20th Congress. Xi ultimately has to rely on the military to make sure that his ambition to perpetuate power won't be dashed.

Views expressed in this article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Ching Cheong is a graduate of the University of Hong Kong. In his decades-long journalism career, he has specialized in political, military, and diplomatic news in Hong Kong, Beijing, Taipei, and Singapore.
Related Topics