Man Issued Ticket for Singing in His Car Plans to Fight It in Court

October 24, 2017 Updated: October 28, 2017

Police issued a man in Montreal, Canada a $118 fine after he told them he was singing in his car.

Taoufik Moalla had just dropped off his children and was headed to buy a bottle of water when four police officers stopped him, looked in his car, and then asked him a question, according to CTV News.

“Then they asked me if I screamed. I said, ‘No, I was just singing,’” said Moalla to CTV News.

He heard his favorite song come on the radio. The 90’s dance anthem “Gonna Make You Sweat (Everybody Dance Now)” by C+C Music Factory.

“I don’t know if my voice was very bad and that’s why I got the ticket, but I was very shocked,” Moalla said. “I understand if they are doing their job, they are allowed to check if everything’s okay, if I kidnapped someone or if there’s danger inside but I would never expect they would give me a ticket for that.”

A Thump article says the original song was “scream-sung” by vocalist Martha Wash. If Moalla was imitating her style, it may have come across as screaming to police. But Moalla said he wasn’t singing very loud. Screaming in public in Montreal can result in a fine of anywhere from $50 to $1,000 Canadian dollars the first time, and then $100 to $2,000 for repeat infractions.

The police checked Moalla’s license and registration before issuing him a ticket for screaming. The ticket says he’ll have to pay $149 Canadian dollars, which is about $118 in United States currency. He plans to fight the ticket.

“I said, ‘Okay, thank you,’ because I know I can contest the ticket,” he said. “They were doing their job.”

Moalla could wait as much as a year for the court date. He brought up a scenario involving Quebec’s legendary pro hockey team to analyze the fairness of the law.

“Imagine if the Canadiens won a game,” he said. “All the fans are going to scream out of their cars. They’re going to sing. Are you going to give them all tickets?”

But Moalla said his wife would have come down on him even harder if she was among the police officers that day.

“She told me, if it was for singing, I’d have given you a ticket for $300,” he said.