Keystone XL Pipeline Gets Opposition in New York City

November 18, 2014 Updated: October 8, 2018

NEW YORK—Ahead of a U.S. Senate vote on the construction of the Keystone XL oil pipeline, a group of local environmental activists rallied in downtown Manhattan on Tuesday to call for an end to the project.

Construction on the pipeline is already underway, bringing crude oil from Canada to refineries in Nebraska, Texas, and Oklahoma. The project’s next proposed phase, will connect crude oil from tar sands in Alberta, Canada to refineries along the Gulf Coast. The Senate was expected to decide whether or not to approve this phase Tuesday evening.

If completed, the pipeline can transport up to 830,000 barrels of oil per day. Opponents of the pipeline are concerned about the greenhouse gas emissions that would result from increased oil production.

On Tuesday, former gubernatorial candidate Zephyr Teachout was the opening speaker at a rally in Foley Square near City Hall, where she called on governor Andrew Cuomo to take a clear stance on whether he supports the pipeline project. 

“It may not be proposed to go through New York State or New York City, but the effects of it will be felt here,” said Teachout, noting that the effects of increased oil production will impact the environment and have repercussions for everyone. 

“We will feel the asthma caused by ground level ozone that comes from climate change. We will feel the effects of the storm surges, and we know better than anybody that we will feel the effects of hurricanes,” said Teachout—referring to the 2012 Superstorm Sandy that brought considerable damage to city neighborhoods along the coastline.

While New York senators Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand have expressed that they will vote against the pipeline, Teachout said they haven’t done enough. She urged the two senators to pressure President Barack Obama to “never grant authorization” for the project.

As of Tuesday afternoon, it seemed unlikely that the Senate would get the 60 votes needed to guarantee passage of the bill designed to green light the project.

Climate Change

Myrtle E. Williams, who works at a nursing home in the Rockaways, recalled having to evacuate over 140 residents when a blizzard hit the city shortly after Superstorm Sandy. When they returned to the nursing home, there was still no heat or hot water.

Some elderly residents passed away during the ordeal. “When you work in the healthcare field, your residents become your family. And to see them die because of things we could’ve made a change in is, very, very sad and very disheartening,” she said. Williams expressed that a disastrous storm like Sandy could hit again if not enough is done to stop climate change.

Similarly, Alexis Smallwood was displaced from her Rockaways home after the storm, and lived in the Bronx for a year and six months. After Smallwood returned to the neighborhood, a natural gas pipeline got the go-ahead to begin construction. The Rockaway Lateral pipeline brings fracked natural gas through the Gateway National Recreation Area, a federal park, to distribution lines in Flatbush, Brooklyn.

“Every time that drill hits the ground, I can feel the vibrations, and Mother Earth saying, stop. This is not for me,” said Smallwood, who is a community outreach coordinator with Rockaway Wildfire, a community organization that advocates for responsible redevelopment of the Rockaways. 

The rally was organized by local advocates from, the group behind the People’s Climate March in September that drew hundreds of thousands of protestors. 

Josh Fox, the filmmaker behind an Oscar-nominated documentary on natural gas fracking, Gasland, and Michael Premo, an Occupy Wall Street activist, also attended the rally.

Follow Annie on Twitter: @annieeenyc