Is the Chinese Economy a Ponzi Scheme?

Is the Chinese Economy a Ponzi Scheme?
Chinese home buyers visit a housing fair in Yichang, in China's Hubei province on Oct. 1. 2015 (STR/AFP/Getty Images)
Valentin Schmid
11/20/2015
Updated:
12/10/2015

China watchers have long waited for this moment to happen: the moment when the debt bubble finally blows up.

We haven’t seen the explosion yet, but we are getting closer, according to a recent report by Hua Chuang Securities cited by Bloomberg.

The shocking finding: Chinese companies are using as much as 45 percent of new debt issuance just to pay the interest on existing debt. To the tune of $1.2 trillion this year.

“One of the reasons credit is growing is because they are using loans to pay interest payments. The primary need and use for expanded private credit is to fund the interest payments,” says Richard Vague, author of “The Next Economic Disaster.”

(Source: Bloomberg)
(Source: Bloomberg)

Source: McKinsey
Source: McKinsey

“If you go back to the Beijing Olympics in 2008, China was this miracle growth economy. Two Olympics later China is a debt story, no longer a growth story,” says Fraser Howie, author of “Red Capitalism.”

When banks cut off this last resort of Ponzi financing, the company follows the same fate as Charles Ponzi or Bernie Madoff: default.

Only three years ago the term “default” was unheard of in China, but this year already six companies could not meet their payments. 

“When I was in China in the late ‘90s underwriting bonds, people just assumed there is no default risk, the government will bail you out,” says Howie.

“Will they allow defaults? This is critical to see whether they allow the market to function,” says Diana Choyleva, chief economist at Lombard Street Research.

Given the huge amount of Ponzi financing, the answer is probably no, at least not for the time being.

“One of the dangers when you’ve got a credit boom like that going is you’re terrified of keeping it going. If you keep it going for longer, you’re going to have a worse problem when you eventually stop,” says Adair Turner, the former British Financial Services Authority chief and author of “Between Debt and the Devil.”

“But you’re terrified of stopping it because the moment you stop it, you’re going to have a whole load of unemployed builders and steel mills with excess capacity.”

Valentin Schmid is a former business editor for the Epoch Times. His areas of expertise include global macroeconomic trends and financial markets, China, and Bitcoin. Before joining the paper in 2012, he worked as a portfolio manager for BNP Paribas in Amsterdam, London, Paris, and Hong Kong.
Related Topics