German Lawmakers Approve Plan to Phase Out Coal, Nuclear

German Lawmakers Approve Plan to Phase Out Coal, Nuclear
A bucket wheel excavator removes overburden at a coal mine near Hambach Forest, Dueren, Germany, on Aug. 27, 2018. (Martin Meissner/AP Photo)
The Associated Press
7/3/2020
Updated:
7/5/2020

BERLIN—German lawmakers have finalized the country’s long-awaited phaseout of coal as an energy source, backing a plan that environmental groups say isn’t ambitious enough and free marketeers criticize as a waste of taxpayers’ money.

Measure approved by both houses of parliament on July 3 envision shutting down the last coal-fired power plant by 2038 and spending some 40 billion ($45 billion) to help affected regions cope with the transition.

The plan is part of Germany’s ‘energy transition’—an effort to wean Europe’s biggest economy off planet-warming fossil fuels and generate all of the country’s considerable energy needs from renewable sources. Achieving that goal is made harder than in comparable countries such as France and Britain because of Germany’s existing commitment to also phase out nuclear power by the end of 2022.

“The days of coal are numbered in Germany,” Environment Minister Svenja Schulze said. “Germany is the first industrialized country that leaves behind both nuclear energy and coal.”

The controversial most modern Uniper Datteln 4 coal-powered plant steams one month after the operational start in Datteln, Germany, on July 3, 2020. (Martin Meissner/AP Photo)
The controversial most modern Uniper Datteln 4 coal-powered plant steams one month after the operational start in Datteln, Germany, on July 3, 2020. (Martin Meissner/AP Photo)

Greenpeace and other environmental groups have staged vocal protests against the plan, including by dropping a banner down the front of the Reichstag building on July 3. They argue that the government’s road map won’t reduce Germany’s greenhouse gas emissions fast enough to meet the targets set out in the Paris climate accord.

“Germany, the country that burns the greatest amount of lignite coal worldwide, will burden the next generation with 18 more years of carbon dioxide,” Greenpeace Germany’s Executive Director Martin Kaiser told The Associated Press.

Kaiser, who was part of a government-appointed expert commission, accused Chancellor Angela Merkel of making a “historic mistake,” saying an end date for coal of 2030 would have sent a strong signal for European and global climate policy. Merkel has said she wants Europe to be the first continent to end its greenhouse gas emissions, by 2050.

Activists of Greenpeace have covered the headquarters of German Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democratic Party (CDU) with black panels to protest against the party's coal policy in Berlin, on July 1, 2020. (Michael Sohn/AP Photo)
Activists of Greenpeace have covered the headquarters of German Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democratic Party (CDU) with black panels to protest against the party's coal policy in Berlin, on July 1, 2020. (Michael Sohn/AP Photo)

While Germany closed its last black coal mine in 2018, it continues to import the fuel and extract its own reserves of lignite, a brownish coal that is abundant in the west and east of the country. Officials warn that the loss of mining jobs could hurt those economically fragile regions, though efforts are already underway to turn the vast lignite mines into nature reserves and lakeside resorts.

Schulze said there would be regular government reviews to examine whether the end date for coal can be brought forward. She noted that by the end of 2022, eight of the country’s most polluting coal-fired plants will have already been closed.

Environmentalists have also criticized the large sums being offered to coal companies to shut down their plants, a complaint shared by libertarians such as Germany’s opposition Free Democratic Party.

Activists of Greenpeace covered the inscription 'Dem Deutschen Volke' (To the German People) on top of the entrance of the Reichstag building, home of the German parliament Bundestag, with the slogan 'Eine Zukunft Ohne Kohlekraft' (a future without coal power) in Berlin, on July 3, 2020. (Michael Sohn/AP Photo)
Activists of Greenpeace covered the inscription 'Dem Deutschen Volke' (To the German People) on top of the entrance of the Reichstag building, home of the German parliament Bundestag, with the slogan 'Eine Zukunft Ohne Kohlekraft' (a future without coal power) in Berlin, on July 3, 2020. (Michael Sohn/AP Photo)

Katja Suding, a leading FDP lawmaker, said the government should have opted to expand existing emissions trading systems that put a price on carbon, thereby encouraging operators to shut down unprofitable coal plants.

“You just have to make it so expensive that it’s not profitable anymore to turn coal into electricity,” she said.

This week, utility companies in Spain shut seven of the country’s 15 coal-fired power plants, saying they couldn’t be operated at profit without government subsidies.

But the head of Germany’s main miners’ union, Michael Vassiliadis, welcomed the decision, calling it a “historic milestone.” He urged the government to focus next on expanding renewable energy generation and the use of hydrogen, which is being touted as a long-term replacement for natural gas.

According to Germany’s state-funded Fraunhofer Institute, some 55.7 percent of net electricity generated so far this year for the public power supply came from renewable sources including wind, solar, biomass, and hydro. Coal accounted for almost 20 percent, followed by nuclear and natural gas with about 12 percent each.

By Frank Jordans