DACA Plaintiff Looks Forward to Supreme Court Hearing

By The Associated Press
The Associated Press
The Associated Press
November 12, 2019 Updated: November 12, 2019

NEW YORK—A Mexican immigrant fighting President Donald Trump’s attempt to end a program shielding young immigrants from deportation says he is nervous about the case finally being heard by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Martín Batalla Vidal is a lead plaintiff in one of the cases to preserve the Obama-era program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and has seen his name in legal documents since 2016, when he first sued in New York.

The 29-year-old certified nursing assistant at a rehabilitation clinic for traumatic brain injury in Queens, New York, has described the legal journey since then as stressful, with people sending him hateful messages. He has had to sacrifice days at work so he could go to protests, press conferences, and meetings with attorneys.

“I don’t know what is going to happen,” said Batalla Vidal, who lives with his mother and two brothers in an apartment at the border of Queens and Brooklyn. “Whatever the outcome is, we know that we have fought hard for it and we will continue fighting. I am trying to be positive.”

The nation’s highest court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on the case on Nov. 12.

Epoch Times Photo
Luz Aurora Vidal and her son, Martín Batalla Vidal, line up to take a bus to Washington, in New York on Nov. 11, 2019. AP Photo/Mark Lennihan

The program allows about 700,000 people who were brought to the United States illegally as children, or who came with families who overstayed visas, to live, work, and study in the country. These immigrants are often referred to as “Dreamers.”

With the attempted elimination of DACA, there was renewed pressure in Congress to pass the DREAM Act, or Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors, a series of never-passed proposals to protect such immigrants from deportation. Opponents say the law rewards people for breaking the law, encourages illegal immigration, and hurts U.S. workers.

Trump ordered an end to DACA in 2017, but federal courts in different states, including New York because of Batalla Vidal’s lawsuit, blocked him from ending it immediately.

The protections will remain in effect at least until the U.S. Supreme Court issues its decision, which will likely be in 2020. Participants of the program can renew their status, but no new applicants can sign up.

The Obama administration created DACA in 2012 to provide Social Security numbers, work permits, and deportation protection to people who, in many cases, have no memory of any home other than the United States.

The Trump administration argues that the program is unlawful because then-President Barack Obama didn’t have the authority to adopt it in the first place. Obama himself acknowledged that he didn’t have the constitutional authority to suspend the deportations of DACA youth. In May 2011, he said he couldn’t “just bypass Congress and change the (immigration) law myself. … That’s not how a democracy works.”

Batalla Vidal initially sued when a federal court in a separate case ruled that DACA permits couldn’t be extended for a third year, as the Obama administration wanted. Now he’s part of the legal fight about the program’s very existence. When President Trump ordered the termination of the program, lawyers for Batalla Vidal amended his original lawsuit to fight the termination and added more individual plaintiffs.

A federal judge ruled in their favor. The U.S. Supreme Court in June agreed to hear the administration’s appeal of Batalla Vidal’s and other cases from around the country.

On Nov. 11, Batalla Vidal planned to arrive to Washington on a bus with his mother to join representatives from colleges, civil rights groups, Democratic-led states, and individuals who also sued. On Nov. 12, he will sit at the Supreme Court to hear oral arguments.

“Nobody thought we would get this far,” he said after speaking last week in a conference at LaGuardia Community College, where he studies criminal justice as an undergraduate student. “I have my family, my community, which has had my back since day one.”

Batalla Vidal crossed the Mexico border when he was 7 years old with his mother and a brother. He has two other brothers who are U.S. citizens.

After going to high school in Brooklyn, he said he worked making deliveries at a deli and later worked at a gym to save for college, and later on to support his single mother who suffers from chronic conditions including osteoarthritis.

Batalla Vidal also joined Make the Road New York, a nonprofit group that defends immigrant rights. Lawyers from the organization, along with the Worker and Immigrant Rights Advocacy Clinic of Yale Law School and the National Immigration Law Center, filed the 2016 lawsuit.

“Martín is fighting for the freedom to thrive and be himself in this country, which is his home,” said Marielena Hincapié, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center.

The Epoch Times contributed to this report.

By Claudia Torrens


The Associated Press
The Associated Press