Suspected Chinese Spy Spun Web of Influence Among US Politicians: Report

Suspected Chinese Spy Spun Web of Influence Among US Politicians: Report
A person walks past the Chinese Consulate in San Francisco on July 23, 2020. (Philip Pacheco/AFP via Getty Images)
Frank Fang

An alleged Chinese spy worked closely with the Chinese Consulate in San Francisco to cozy up to several U.S. politicians in the Bay Area before she abruptly left the United States in 2015.

The spy, named Fang Fang or Christine Fang, was allegedly working for the Ministry of State Security (MSS), China’s chief intelligence agency. She maintained “unusually close ties” with the Chinese Consulate after she enrolled as a student at California State University–East Bay (CSUEB) in 2011, according to a recent investigative report by Axios.

The publication spoke to 26 current and former elected U.S. officials, political operatives, former students, and current and former U.S. intelligence officials in its year-long investigation.

According to the outlet, Fang was believed to have helped place “unwitting subagents” in local political and congressional offices, but it was unlikely that she received or passed on classified information. Nonetheless, she collected private information about U.S. officials.

She also used campaign fundraising, networking, and romantic or sexual relations with at least two mayors from cities in the Midwest to “gain proximity to political power,” according to Axios.

Fang’s alleged efforts to infiltrate the U.S. political system came to light just days after Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe warned that Chinese agents were targeting members of Congress and congressional aides, in a commentary published in The Wall Street Journal.
Chinese agents with ties to the MSS have recently been prosecuted in a number of U.S. criminal cases. In March, a California man who was recruited by the MSS during his trip to China in 2015 was sentenced to four years in prison after he was found guilty of handing over classified U.S. national security information to MSS officials in China.
Fang was active in CSUEB campus activities, serving as president of the university’s Chinese Student Association and president of the school’s chapter of the Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs, a nonprofit that encourages Asian Americans to be involved in civic and public affairs.

She grew her influence among U.S. politicians by attending regional mayoral conferences.

In one instance, Fang had a sexual encounter with an unnamed Ohio mayor in a car that was under FBI surveillance. She told the mayor she was interested in him because “she wanted to improve her English,” according to the outlet.

Fang also became close with Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-Calif.). According to the outlet, she helped raise money for the lawmaker’s 2014 reelection campaign, although she didn’t make any donations herself, nor was there evidence of illegal contributions.

Swalwell’s office, in a statement to Axios, said the lawmaker ended ties with Fang in 2015 after he was alerted by federal investigators about their concerns regarding Fang’s activities.

Fang came under the attention of federal investigators during their surveillance of another suspected MSS officer, who worked undercover as a diplomat at the Chinese Consulate in San Francisco, according to the outlet.

“The suspected officer used the consulate as a base to do outreach to state and local-level U.S. politicians, including inviting them on trips to China,” an unnamed current U.S. counterintelligence official told Axios.

After reading the Axios report, Rep. Rick Crawford (R-Ark.) expressed concerns about Beijing on Twitter: “I’ve long sounded the alarm on how China cannot be trusted. They’re a country who seeks to dominate and destroy anyone in their path.”
Chinese Consulates in the United States have been coming under increased scrutiny in recent months. In July, the Chinese Consulate in San Francisco was accused of harboring a Chinese military researcher wanted by the FBI. In the same month, the State Department ordered the Chinese Consulate in Houston to close down, as the diplomatic outpost was being used as a “spy center.”