Multi-Level Marketing Giant Herbalife Agrees to Pay $123 Million to Settle Chinese Bribery Case

Cathy He

Multi-level marketing giant Herbalife Nutrition Ltd. has agreed to $123 million to settle federal charges that it bribed Chinese officials to advance its business in China, the U.S. Department of Justice said on Aug. 28.

Herbalife, a Los Angeles-based multi-level marketing company that sells health and dietary supplements, admitted to engaging in a decade-long scheme to bribe Chinese officials and falsifying its books to conceal such payments, the department said.

The company entered into a three-year deferred prosecution agreement, in which it admitted to conspiring to violate the books and records provision of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, an anti-bribery law. It also reached a parallel agreement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Prosecutors said that from 2007 to 2016, Herbalife schemed to bribe Chinese officials with cash, entertainment, meals, and travel to obtain direct selling licenses for its Chinese subsidiary, reduce government scrutiny, and remove negative coverage by state-controlled media. During that period, Herbalife obtained direct sale licenses in 28 Chinese provinces, court documents said.

By 2016, Herbalife's China business accounted for about 20 percent—$860 million—of the company's global annual net sales, prosecutors said.

"Herbalife approved the extensive and systematic corrupt payments to Chinese government officials over a 10-year period to promote and expand Herbalife’s business in China,” acting U.S. Attorney of the Southern District of New York Audrey Strauss said in a statement.

“Moreover, in an effort to conceal this widespread corruption scheme, Herbalife maintained false accounting records to mischaracterize these improper payments as permissible business expenses."

The company will pay a $55 million criminal fine, as well as $67 million to the SEC in a related civil case.

Last November, U.S. prosecutors filed related corruption charges against Li Yanliang, who led Herbalife's Chinese unit, and Yang Hongwei, who led its external affairs department. Both are Chinese citizens and remain at-large.
Six weeks earlier, Herbalife agreed to pay $20 million to settle SEC charges that it misled investors about its Chinese business.

Court documents in the present case listed numerous instances wherein Li, Yang, or other unnamed Chinese executives allegedly arranged to have cash—some of it stuffed into "red envelopes"—or gift vouchers delivered to Chinese officials.

In March 2007, for instance, Li and Yang were discussing whether to pay 35,000 yuan ($5,000) to officials at a government agency to reduce the risk of future penalties against Herbalife China.

During that conversation, Li said: "I was thinking it would be better to spend money beforehand than spend money afterwards. This money is a small sum after all, and if we were to be penalized, the figure will be much greater," according to court documents.

In November 2007, an unnamed high-level executive told Li that he or she wanted to live in Shanghai, but "for legal reasons" the move would be "too risky." "There's something called the FCPA, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and all of that stuff," the executive said, according to court documents.

Herbalife shares fell 0.32 percent to $49.52 at close on Friday.

The company did not respond to a request for comment.

Reuters contributed to this report. 
Cathy He is an editor focusing on U.S. and China-related topics. She previously worked as a government lawyer in Australia. She joined The Epoch Times in February 2018. Contact Cathy at [email protected].