Why Americans Are Having a Harder Time Getting Credit

(Comstock Images/Getty Images)

In the wake of the failures of several regional banks, Americans across the board are finding it harder to get credit.

Because smaller banks are so critical to small-business and consumer lending, many analysts predict the fallout from the Fed’s campaign to tame inflation will have dire consequences for the economy.

“Bank lending peaked in May of 2020 at 11 percent year-over-year growth,” Steve Hanke, professor of Applied Economics at Johns Hopkins University, told the Epoch Times. “Today, that number has slowed to 5.5 percent per year.

“Following the failures of Silicon Valley Bank, Silvergate Bank, and First Republic Bank, I anticipate that bank lending will continue to decelerate as the credit market tightens up,” said Hanke, who served on President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisors.

According to a March 16 Goldman Sachs report, “as stress ripples through smaller banks in the U.S., the tightening in lending standards among those institutions is expected to reduce economic growth this year.”

Although the failed banks accounted for just 1 percent of total lending, many other banks have similar problems today. Measured as a share of total lending, banks with a high loan-to-deposit ratio provide 20 percent of all loans, banks with a low share of FDIC-insured deposits provide 7 percent, and banks with concentrated deposits provide 4 percent.

Smaller banks, below $250 billion in assets, comprise about half of all business lending, 60 percent of residential real estate lending, 80 percent of commercial real estate lending, and 45 percent of consumer lending, Goldman reports.

In addition, the remaining smaller banks have lost deposits as customers rush to larger banks and money market funds, economist Mohamed El-Erian writes in a Financial Times op-ed, and the loans they provide “are unlikely to be undertaken at any scale by the beneficiaries of deposit outflows.”

“We are heading towards a credit crunch,” Hanke said. “We know that a recession is baked in the cake because the money supply (M2) has been sharply contracting, falling by 2.9 percent since March 2022.”

M2 represents cash and short-term bank deposits; this measure is seen as a key indicator of inflation if it outpaces GDP, or recession if it lags.

“Unfortunately, the Fed doesn’t pay any attention to the growth rate in the money supply,” Hanke said. “As a result, it has dramatically increased the Fed funds rate and engaged in [quantitative tightening].

“This deadly cocktail has plunged the money supply (M2) by 2.9 percent since March 2022,” he said. “At present, the year-over-year growth rate of the M2 is -2.4 percent, whereas the golden growth rate, as I calculate it which is consistent with hitting a 2 percent inflation target, is around 5.5 percent. This spells trouble for the credit market.”

President and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis James Bullard in Washington on Aug. 6, 2019. (Alastair Pike/AFP via Getty Images)

James Bullard, president of the St. Louis Fed, acknowledged the credit crunch on April 6, but said it was “too soon to tell what kind of tightening we are seeing.”

“Only about 20 percent of lending is going through the banking system, and only a fraction of the banks are small and regional banks,” he said. “I just don’t think it is big enough by itself to send the U.S. economy into recession.”

A March 22 statement by the Fed indicated it believes that while the banking crisis is “likely to result in tighter credit conditions for households and businesses and to weigh on economic activity, hiring, and inflation … the extent of these effects is uncertain.” The Fed stated that it “remains highly attentive to inflation risks,” indicating that additional interest rate hikes may be forthcoming.

An April Fed consumer survey found that inflation expectations increased by 0.5 percent in March to 4.7 percent, marking the first increase since October 2022. Simultaneously, Americans’ expected average wage growth was 3 percent, indicating a continuing deterioration in living standards relative to inflation, while “the share of households reporting it is harder to obtain credit than one year ago [is] rising and reaching a series high.”

The Fed policy of quantitative tightening (QT) follows a decade of quantitative easing (QE), in which the Fed accumulated nearly $9 trillion in bonds between the 2008 mortgage crisis and the 2020 COVID lockdowns.

Through an experimental strategy, it accumulated treasury bonds and mortgage-backed securities in unprecedented quantities, flooding the market with dollars to drive longer term rates down, while keeping short-term rates near zero—all in an ongoing effort to stimulate the economy and prop up asset values.

The expanding balance sheet of the Federal Reserve Bank. Source Federal Reserve

Now that the Fed is beginning to shift into reverse to combat inflation, it is embarking on an equally experimental policy of downsizing its balance sheet. The consequences of QT on the banking system and the economy are effectively a guessing game.

According to some economists, the Fed should focus on the money supply as the key driver of inflation and not get distracted by other factors.

“The Fed should be paying attention to the Quantity Theory of Money, and should stop its obsession with data-dependency and chasing what are a thousand irrelevant rabbits at the same time,” Hanke said. “In short, the Fed is paying attention to the noise and missing the signal.”