US Police Agencies With Their Own DNA Databases Stir Debate

US Police Agencies With Their Own DNA Databases Stir Debate
An evidence marker sits next to a human skull as Davis County search and rescue members and crime scene investigators search a hillside, for more evidence in Fruit Heights, Utah on Feb. 6, 2015. More police departments are amassing their own DNA databases, a move critics say is a way around stringent regulations governing state crime labs and the national DNA database. Scott G Winterton/Deseret News via AP, File
|Updated:

LOS ANGELES—Dozens of police departments around the U.S. are amassing their own DNA databases to track criminals, a move critics say is a way around regulations governing state and national databases that restrict who can provide genetic samples and how long that information is held.

The local agencies create the rules for their databases, in some cases allowing samples to be taken from children or from people never arrested for a crime. Police chiefs say having their own collections helps them solve cases faster because they can avoid the backlogs that plague state and federal repositories.

Frederick Harran, the public safety director in Bensalem Township, Pennsylvania, was an early adopter of a local database. Since it was created in 2010, he said robberies and burglaries have gone down due to arrests made because of the DNA collection.

Harran said the Pennsylvania state lab takes up to 18 months to process DNA taken from a burglary scene but with the local database authorities go through a private lab and get results within a month. He said he uses money from assets seized from criminals to pay for the private lab work.

“If they are burglarizing and we don’t get them identified in 18 to 24 months, they have two years to keep committing crimes,” he said.

Senior Criminalist Heide Elliott works on extracting DNA at the State of California Department of Justice Jan Bashinski DNA Laboratory in Richmond, Calif. on Feb. 17, 2012 More police departments are amassing their own DNA databases, a move critics say is a way around stringent regulations governing state crime labs and the national DNA database. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File)
Senior Criminalist Heide Elliott works on extracting DNA at the State of California Department of Justice Jan Bashinski DNA Laboratory in Richmond, Calif. on Feb. 17, 2012 More police departments are amassing their own DNA databases, a move critics say is a way around stringent regulations governing state crime labs and the national DNA database. AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File