NY School Problems Highlight Debate Over Outside ‘Receivers’

NY School Problems Highlight Debate Over Outside ‘Receivers’
New York City Education Department Chancellor Carmen Fariña visits P.S. 15 Roberto Clemente Elementary School in Manhattan on Dec. 1, 2014. P.S. 15 is on the state list of struggling schools. Petr Svab/Epoch Times
|Updated:

BUFFALO, N.Y.—The clock is ticking for leaders of New York’s most chronically underperforming public schools, who under a new state law must quickly begin to turn things around or lose control to an outsider—a tactic that has produced mixed results elsewhere.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo points to Massachusetts, where education officials say giving a state-appointed leader, or receiver, the freedom to lengthen school days, replace principals, and make other changes has been working.

But with 144 schools in 17 New York districts now targeted, opinions vary on whether taking schools, and broad powers, away from school boards is the answer.

Receivership is the state’s way of shifting the blame from its own failure to adequately support struggling schools, most of which are in impoverished districts, said Karen Magee, president of New York State United Teachers.

The 20 schools statewide that are classified as persistently struggling will start the upcoming school year in the receivership of their districts' superintendents.