Idaho Juvenile Justice More Secretive Than Adult System

Idaho Juvenile Justice More Secretive Than Adult System
Attorney Brad Calbo, whose law firm acts as the public defenders for Jerome County’s felony juvenile cases, says Idaho needs to better fund treatment for juvenile offenders, on Sept. 15, 2016. Pat Sutphin/The Times-News via AP
|Updated:

TWIN FALLS, Idaho—When police arrest a man suspected of robbing a bank, you see his name in breaking news alerts. When a woman gets a prison sentence, you see her mug shot on the newspaper’s front page.

But when the suspect in an assault or a theft is a juvenile, you may learn almost nothing about the case.

As Magic Valley’s recent high-profile juveniles cases have shown, Idaho’s juvenile justice system is far different than the adult criminal justice system and often much more secretive, reported The Times-News.

When three Dietrich High School football players were charged in March in connection with the sexual assault of a teammate, only the names of the two players charged as adults were made public, while the third boy’s case was completely sealed. When a gun went off at Robert Stuart Middle School in May, officials released very limited information, saying only that three juveniles had been detained; their names and the results of their cases remain sealed. And when allegations began to swirl around the reported sexual assault of a young girl at the Fawnbrook Apartments in June, officials spoke out only to dispel rumors about the case.

School resource officer Matt Triner shows what a juvenile status offender referral looks like at Canyon Ridge High School in Twin Falls, Idaho, on Sept. 1, 2016. (Drew Nash/The Times-News via AP)
School resource officer Matt Triner shows what a juvenile status offender referral looks like at Canyon Ridge High School in Twin Falls, Idaho, on Sept. 1, 2016. Drew Nash/The Times-News via AP