The Long Arm of Beijing: Inquiry Hears of CCP’s ‘Extensive’ Campaign Against Falun Gong in Canada

The Long Arm of Beijing: Inquiry Hears of CCP’s ‘Extensive’ Campaign Against Falun Gong in Canada
(L-R) Diaspora members Hamed Esmaeilion, Grace Wollensak, Mehmet Tohti, and Yuriy Novodvorskiy appear at the Public Inquiry Into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes and Democratic Institutions, in Ottawa on March 27, 2024. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)
Noé Chartier
3/27/2024
Updated:
3/28/2024
0:00

Chinese Communist Party agents manipulating politicians, physical and verbal abuse of Falun Gong adherents, and the spreading of regime-instigated hate through media are some of the challenges faced by the Falun Gong community in Canada, the foreign interference inquiry heard on March 27.

Representatives of diaspora groups who report being targeted by a foreign power opened the new round of hearings at the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference in Ottawa.

The purpose of the inquiry is to hear evidence about interference in the 2019 and 2021 federal elections, but it started with testimony from communities that are more broadly targeted by foreign actors and transnational repression.

Grace Wollensak, speaking on behalf of the Falun Gong community, detailed what she called an “extensive foreign interference and repression” campaign in Canada waged by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) over the past two decades.

She described Falun Gong as a meditation practice with moral teachings introduced in China in 1992. By 1999 it had gained huge popularity, which she said explains in part why the CCP started persecuting the group.

Falun Gong principles of truthfulness, compassion, and tolerance are “incompatible with communist atheist ideology,” Ms. Wollensak said, adding that then-CCP leader Jiang Zemin, who made the decision to eradicate the group, saw its popularity as a threat to his power.

The repression campaign launched in China, which includes defamation, imprisonment, forced labour, torture, and forced organ harvesting, has extended to Canada with an array of tactics, she said. Examples include regime agents impersonating Falun Gong practitioners and sending offensive emails to politicians to try to discredit the group.

On one occasion, she was contacted by the RCMP after MPs complained about receiving emails from someone pretending to be a Falun Gong adherent.

“This is a systematic attack orchestrated by the CCP agents or the CCP themselves to try to discredit Falun Gong practitioners,” Ms. Wollensak said.

There has also been “persistent” physical and verbal assault and harassment by CCP agents against Falun Gong adherents in Canada, she said, including one practitioner being held “at gunpoint” while protesting outside the Chinese consulate in Vancouver.

In another incident, a Toronto adherent was confronted at her door and threatened with her children being taken away. She had been outspoken in asking for the release of her sister and brother-in-law who were illegally imprisoned by the CCP in China for their belief in Falun Gong.

“On another occasion, her car windows were smashed and her balcony was spread by human excretions,” she said.

Ms. Wollensak also described the CCP’s control of Chinese-language media to demonize the group and said Canadian media have sometimes been misled into using the CCP’s vocabulary to describe practitioners.

She said matters improved after protests were lodged with media outlets, although the situation remains dire when it comes to Canada’s Chinese-language media, which are often CCP-controlled.

A man disrupts a Falun Gong rally outside the Chinese Consulate in Calgary on Aug. 21, 2017. (Handout)
A man disrupts a Falun Gong rally outside the Chinese Consulate in Calgary on Aug. 21, 2017. (Handout)

Ms. Wollensak also recounted how municipal officials from Canada, after taking trips to China, had withdrawn their support for Falun Gong or took action to stifle their protests against the Chinese regime.

In 2006, then-Vancouver mayor Sam Sullivan pursued court action to remove a long-standing Falun Gong vigil outside the Chinese consulate. “When I go to China, they treat me like an emperor,” Mr. Sullivan told the Vancouver Sun that same year.

Ms. Wollensak became emotional when recounting efforts by Ottawa city officials to lessen the footprint of a protest she organized in front of the Chinese embassy, calling it an example of Beijing influencing local authorities. After many efforts the issue was resolved, but she said the group shouldn’t have to go through such ordeals.

Beijing’s influence was also felt in 2010 when then-Ottawa mayor Larry O'Brien, after returning from a trip to China, pulled his support for a proclamation recognizing Falun Gong adherents, reportedly because of a “commitment” he had made, the Ottawa Citizen reported. City council sidestepped the mayor and unanimously approved the declaration honouring Falun Gong, which the city continued to do in subsequent years.
Ms. Wollensak referenced a comprehensive report published by the Falun Dafa Association of Canada in October 2023 which profiles the extent of CCP persecutory tactics in Canada and makes a series of recommendations.
They include publicly condemning CCP persecution of Falun Gong, sanctioning Chinese diplomats and officials involved in infiltration and persecution activities, and enacting a foreign agent registry.

‘Cost of Advocacy’

Another representative of a diaspora group targeted by Beijing who testified before the inquiry was Mehmet Tohti, director of the Uyghur Rights Advocacy Project.

The Uyghurs, a Turkic Muslim minority from northwestern China, have long been repressed by Beijing and are subject to mass arbitrary detention. In a 2021 motion the House of Commons declared their treatment by the CCP a genocide.

Mr. Tohti said the price to pay for advocacy is high, recounting a call he received from Chinese police telling him that his mother and two sisters were dead. The call came just weeks before a House of Commons vote on a motion calling for the resettlement of 10,000 Uyghurs. He later confirmed his mother had died in a concentration camp at age 76.

The Chinese regime was “sending that kind of message and implying that this was the cost you have to pay if you continue to advocate,” he said, adding there is also “a lack of protection in Canada.”

Representatives from the Iranian, Russian, and Sikh communities also spoke about their experiences and concerns regarding foreign interference.

Disclosure of Information

The March 27 session opened with Commissioner Marie-Josée Hogue summarizing the first round of hearings that were held in January and focused on how the inquiry should deal with classified information.

Ms. Hogue said the January hearings showed that protecting certain types of information may be essential to safeguarding national security and respecting international commitments.

On the other hand, disclosing some of that information could help educate the public to recognize and respond to foreign interference attempts, she said.

The commissioner said the fact that some of the information related to foreign interference is protected and highly classified has not hampered the inquiry.

“Confidentiality imperatives have so far not prevented us from doing the work we have been tasked to do,” she said.

Commissioner Justice Marie-Josée Hogue is seen during the second day of the Public Inquiry Into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes and Democratic Institutions, in Ottawa, on Jan.30, 2024. (The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld)
Commissioner Justice Marie-Josée Hogue is seen during the second day of the Public Inquiry Into Foreign Interference in Federal Electoral Processes and Democratic Institutions, in Ottawa, on Jan.30, 2024. (The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld)

The inquiry was launched after political parties held negotiations over the summer to decide on terms of reference and choose a commissioner.

The Liberal government had initially resisted holding an inquiry. Amid a growing body of national security leaks reported in the press and mounting political pressure, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau appointed former governor general David Johnston as special rapporteur on foreign interference in March 2023.

Mr. Johnston concluded in his report tabled in May 2023 that in order to protect national security information a foreign interference inquiry should not be held. He resigned in June under pressure from Opposition parties.

CSIS leaks published in the press have depicted widespread interference by Beijing in Canada’s democratic process. Some of the allegations published were addressed by Mr. Johnston in his report.

For example, he confirmed that intelligence shows there were “irregularities” in the 2019 Liberal nomination of Han Dong in the Ontario riding of Don Valley North. “There is well-grounded suspicion that the irregularities were tied to the [Chinese] Consulate in Toronto, with whom Dong maintains relationships,” the report said.

Mr. Trudeau was briefed on the irregularities but chose to leave Mr. Dong in his position.

Mr. Dong left the Liberal caucus in March 2023 and has sued Global News over its initial coverage of the intelligence, claiming it was defamatory.

The MP, who now sits as an Independent, has full standing at the public inquiry and will testify as a witness. Mr. Trudeau and other government officials are also expected to appear before the inquiry in coming days.