White Gold: Rival 18th-Century Porcelain Manufactories

Nationalism intensified the rivalry of the two greatest 18th-century European porcelain manufactories: Meissen and Sèvres.
White Gold: Rival 18th-Century Porcelain Manufactories
A detail of “Vase (elephant head vase) (one of a pair),” circa 1758, by Jean-Claude Duplessis from the Sèvres Manufactory. (Public Domain)
3/25/2024
Updated:
3/25/2024
0:00

The history of porcelain dates back around 2,000 years to China. Porcelain is a vitrified, translucent white ceramic usually made from the materials kaolin, a type of clay, and petuntse, a kind of mineral, fired at high temperature. Its legacy in the West is much more recent. Chinese porcelain was first imported into Europe in the 14th century.

Europeans became infatuated with the fragile, yet durable, material that they referred to as “white gold,” and their royalty assembled vast collections of it. Not content with buying exports, European rulers wanted to make their own porcelain tableware and decorative objects. No European cracked the code of producing true porcelain, known as hard-paste, until the early 18th century.

The two greatest 18th century European porcelain manufactories were Meissen and Sèvres (originally known as Vincennes). Nationalism intensified these companies’ rivalry. Meissen was made in Saxony (part of present-day Germany) and Sèvres was French, fabricated outside of Paris.

Augustus’s Porcelain Sickness

A portrait of Augustus II the Strong, circa 1720, by Louis de Silvestre. Oil on canvas. Nationalmuseum, Stockholm, Sweden. (Public Domain)
A portrait of Augustus II the Strong, circa 1720, by Louis de Silvestre. Oil on canvas. Nationalmuseum, Stockholm, Sweden. (Public Domain)
The ruler of Saxony, Augustus II, was obsessed with porcelain, to put it mildly. The elector, best known as Augustus the Strong, diagnosed himself with “Porzellankrankheit,” or porcelain sickness. By the time of his death, he owned more than 35,000 pieces.

Augustus held the alchemist Johann Friedrich Böttger prisoner in Dresden, the capital of Saxony, forcing him to experiment with porcelain recipes. It was Böttger and his collaborators who succeeded in replicating true porcelain for the first time in the West. The Meissen factory was then established in 1710 under the royal patronage of Augustus.

Meissen dominated in Europe for the next 40 years until its prestige was eclipsed by King Louis XV of France’s royal manufactory.

A Meissen Masterpiece

Mantel clock (pendule) with Arachne and Athena, 1727, attributed to Johann Gottlieb Kirchner from the Meissen Porcelain Manufactory. Porcelain with metal gilding; 17 3/10 inches by  8 1/5 inches by 5 3/10 inches. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. (Public Domain)
Mantel clock (pendule) with Arachne and Athena, 1727, attributed to Johann Gottlieb Kirchner from the Meissen Porcelain Manufactory. Porcelain with metal gilding; 17 3/10 inches by  8 1/5 inches by 5 3/10 inches. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. (Public Domain)

A masterpiece of Meissen’s early period is a mantel clock (pendule) with Arachne and Athena, now owned rightfully by the Rijksmuseum. This object has a complex decorative scheme and provenance. Scholars believe it may have been made for Augustus. It passed through illustrious owners in the 19th century before entering the collection of the Berlin couple Franz and Margarethe Oppenheimer.

The Oppenheimers fled the city for Vienna after Hitler’s rise to power; they later managed to escape Austria. Before their flight from persecution in Vienna, the Oppenheimers sold their storied Meissen holdings to a Dutch collector, who died shortly after. The Nazis purchased the porcelain collection. After World War II, the Allies recovered it from the salt mines, and its ownership reverted to the Dutch State, which deposited it at the Rijksmuseum.

In 2019, the Netherlands restituted the collection to the Oppenheimers’ heirs. Two years later, Sotheby’s auctioned it on their behalf, and the Rijksmuseum bought back more than half of the lots, including this mantel clock, which was the highlight of the sale. Estimated at $200,000–400,000, it sold for just under $1.6 million.

Sotheby’s catalogue describes the clock as such: “The crisply modelled architectural silhouette is enhanced further by an extraordinary trove of techniques of decoration including exuberantly painted Chinoiserie figural panels, enriched by either puce and iron-red foliate scrollwork, or underglaze-blue borders, and gilt Chinoiserie figures and scrollwork over Böttger-lustre.” The lustrous glaze is a pink-lilac color invented by Böttger. It was often used in Meissen porcelain with Chinoiserie subjects, which are East Asian motifs adapted to European taste.

A detail of the figures Arachne and Athena from amMantel clock (pendule) with Arachne and Athena. (Public Domain)
A detail of the figures Arachne and Athena from amMantel clock (pendule) with Arachne and Athena. (Public Domain)

The figures on top of the clock case’s vaulted dome refers to the mythological tale of the young weaver Arachne and the Greek goddess Athena. In the story, Arachne boasts that her weaving skill is greater than Athena’s. In an ensuing contest, Arachne bests the goddess. Enraged, Athena curses her and turns her into a spider.

Inspiration for their modeling was likely taken from antique and modern sculptures collected by Augustus, notes art historian Maureen Cassidy-Geiger in the Sotheby’s article “Provenance and Prestige: The Margarethe and Franz Oppenheimer Collection.” The first artist to work on the clock case was George Fritzsche until the arrival of sculptor Johann Gottlieb Kirchner, who took over its production and went on later to make some of the most celebrated Meissen commissions.

Porcelain Flowers of Vincennes

A mounted vase with flowers, vase before 1733, flowers from 1745–1750, and mount around 1745–1749, by the Meissen Porcelain Manufactory (vase), and the Vincennes Porcelain Manufactory (flowers). Hard-paste porcelain and polychrome-enamel decoration; soft-paste porcelain; gilt-bronze. Getty Center, Los Angeles. (Public Domain)
A mounted vase with flowers, vase before 1733, flowers from 1745–1750, and mount around 1745–1749, by the Meissen Porcelain Manufactory (vase), and the Vincennes Porcelain Manufactory (flowers). Hard-paste porcelain and polychrome-enamel decoration; soft-paste porcelain; gilt-bronze. Getty Center, Los Angeles. (Public Domain)

France was envious of Saxony’s success with porcelain at the Meissen factory. In 1740, the Vincennes Manufactory was founded in a royal chateau east of Paris. It was run by a former carpenter who had perfected the creation of a whiter, more brilliant soft-paste porcelain. The company’s goal was to produce porcelain to rival that of Meissen. Initially, they made frequent copies of popular Meissen pieces. Louis XV granted Vincennes a royal warrant five years after its founding.

A set of objects at the Getty Center encapsulate this period of porcelain competition. A pair of mounted vases with flowers features Meissen vases from before 1733. The porcelain containers are decorated with painted flowers and insects; shadows are included to give heightened realism. The Getty explains, “The painter carefully placed a few of the smaller bugs to cover flaws in the porcelain.”

A detail of the Vincennes Porcelain Manufactory flowers from a pair of mounted vases with flowers. (Public Domain)
A detail of the Vincennes Porcelain Manufactory flowers from a pair of mounted vases with flowers. (Public Domain)

The bases of the Meissen vases have the monogram of Augustus the Strong, “AR,” painted in blue, and they were imported into France around 1745. Upon their arrival in Paris, a dealer had them set into gilt bronze mounts. Then, Vincennes porcelain flowers were attached to stems by a craftsperson and arranged as a lovely bouquet in the Meissen vase.

Vincennes Porcelain Manufactory became especially known for its naturalistic flowers, which were coveted by stylish and noble Parisians in the 1740s. Some patrons had collections of thousands of flowers modeled after different species. They were used for interior decoration and may even have been misted with perfume to better resemble a lifelike arrangement.

"Louis XV in Coronation Robes," 1730, by Hyacinthe Rigaud. Oil on canvas. Palace of Versailles, France. (Public Domain
"Louis XV in Coronation Robes," 1730, by Hyacinthe Rigaud. Oil on canvas. Palace of Versailles, France. (Public Domain
In 1756, the factory moved to specially built facilities in Sèvres, an area southwest of Paris. The company became known by the name of their new location. Three years later, Louis XV was its sole owner, and its wares were mostly destined for the French royal family and courtiers, akin to Meissen during the reign of Augustus the Strong.

‘Rose Pompadour’

A portrait of Madame de Pompadour, 1756, by François Boucher. Oil on canvas; 79 inches by 61 4/15 inches. Alte Pinakothek, Munich. (Public Domain)
A portrait of Madame de Pompadour, 1756, by François Boucher. Oil on canvas; 79 inches by 61 4/15 inches. Alte Pinakothek, Munich. (Public Domain)

A whimsical pair of vases with elephant heads at The Metropolitan Museum of Art from circa 1758 are stunning examples of Pompadour-approved pink. By this period, due to technical ingenuity and lavish decorative schemes, Sèvres was the leading European manufactory of soft-paste porcelain. They did not make hard-paste porcelain until 1769, two years after kaolin was discovered in Limoges, France.

A vase with elephant heads (one of a pair), circa 1758, by Jean-Claude Duplessis from the Sèvres Manufactory. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City. (Public Domain)
A vase with elephant heads (one of a pair), circa 1758, by Jean-Claude Duplessis from the Sèvres Manufactory. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City. (Public Domain)

Soon, Sèvres no longer relied on Meissen wares for inspiration. Some scholars consider Sèvres’ ornamental vases, richly colored and sumptuously gilded, to be the firm’s greatest achievements. The Met’s symmetrically composed examples were molded by Jean-Claude Duplessis, an Italian-born goldsmith who joined Sèvres in 1748 and innovated new sculptural forms.

The late 1750s saw the creation of some of Sèvres’ most astonishing vase models. They were extremely difficult to produce and costly. Elephant-head vases, with trunks as candleholders, were especially popular with royals and the aristocracy. Madame de Pompadour owned at least three pairs. “Elephants were a subject of much fascination in early modern Europe,” writes Met curator Wolf Burchard in his catalogue “Inspiring Walt Disney: The Animation of French Decorative Arts.”

The Met’s vases were purchased originally by Louis-Joseph de Bourbon, the prince de Condé, at an exclusive sale in Louis XV’s private apartments at Versailles. The prince purchased five vases. The full price was 4,320 livres, a figure in excess of a professional worker’s annual salary. Historians believe that only 22 elephant-head vases have survived to the current day.

After the French Revolution, ownership of the Sèvres Manufactory transferred to the French government. It is still in operation and often collaborates with contemporary artists. Meissen continues production, too, and is now owned by the State of Saxony. Although it is no longer a priority for nations to outpace each other in the production of porcelain, the “porcelain wars” of the 18th century led to the creation of some of the most beautiful European decorative objects.

Would you like to see other kinds of arts and culture articles? Please email us your story ideas or feedback at [email protected] 
Michelle Plastrik is an art adviser living in New York City. She writes on a range of topics, including art history, the art market, museums, art fairs, and special exhibitions.