A U.S. startup company is accusing Chinese telecommunications gear provider Huawei of enlisting a Chinese university professor working on a research project to improperly access the startup’s technology, according to court documents filed last week.
California-based CNEX, which is developing technology to enhance the performance of solid-state drives in data centers, has been locked in a dispute with Huawei Technologies Co. since 2017. In a new set of counterclaims filed in federal court in Texas last week, CNEX claimed that Bo Mao, a professor at Xiamen University, asked for one of the company’s circuit boards as part of a research project.
The company alleges that it required Mao to sign a “strict non-disclosure obligation” about the circuit board. But CNEX claimed that, unbeknownst to it, the university was working with Huawei and alleged that after the component was sent to the professor, technical details about its products ended up in Huawei’s hands.
“Huawei took CNEX’s proprietary and trade secret information and shared it with the personnel developing Huawei’s (solid-state drive) controllers, in violation of representations made to CNEX and restrictions placed on the distribution of CNEX’s technical information,” the startup said in the filing.
Neither Huawei nor Mao returned a request from Reuters for comment.
Huawei’s gear has been largely shut out of the United States since 2012 because of concerns the technology could be used for espionage. The company has said the concerns are unfounded.
The Chinese company’s CFO, Meng Wanzhou, 47, the daughter of Huawei’s billionaire founder, Ren Zhengfei, was arrested at Vancouver’s airport in December on a U.S. warrant on charges that she conspired to defraud global banks about Huawei’s relationship with a company operating in Iran. Meng has said she is innocent and is fighting extradition in a Canadian court.
CNEX’s allegations last week are the latest in a trial dating to 2017. One of CNEX’s co-founders, Ronnie Huang, had worked for a Huawei subsidiary in Texas, but left in 2013 and later helped found CNEX.
In 2017, Huawei sued CNEX and Huang, alleging that the startup’s inventions were related to work Huang had done at Huawei and that it had a right to the patents under a contract that Huang signed. CNEX, in turn, alleged that Huawei was seeking to use the court case itself to obtain deeper access to the startup’s technology through the discovery process.
Last week, the court denied Huawei’s claims to ownership over CNEX’s patents, ruling that California law, which gives workers broad leeway to leave their employers and create new companies, applied to that part of Huang’s contract. CNEX still faces claims from Huawei that Huang improperly recruited his former Huawei co-workers to join his new company.
By Stephen Nellis