US Charges 20 People Over Chinese Birth Tourism Schemes

January 31, 2019 Updated: January 31, 2019

SANTA ANA, California—Twenty people have been charged in the largest-ever crackdown on businesses that help Chinese women travel to the United States to give birth to babies who automatically are American citizens, authorities said Jan. 31.

Three people were arrested in Southern California on charges including conspiracy, visa fraud and money laundering. More than a dozen others have also been charged in cases stemming from three so-called birth tourism businesses, with many believed to be in China, the U.S. Attorney’s office said.

It is the first time the United States has criminally prosecuted birth tourism operators, said Thom Mrozek, a spokesman for the U.S. attorney’s office.

The businesses—which were raided by federal agents in 2015—billed Chinese women tens of thousands of dollars to travel to California to deliver their babies in American hospitals so the children would automatically obtain U.S. citizenship, prosecutors said.

Federal agents gather at a nearby parking lot before raiding an upscale apartment complex where authorities say a birth tourism business charged pregnant women $50,000 for lodging, food and transportation in Irvine, California, U.S. on March 3, 2015. (Jae C. Hong/AP)

It isn’t illegal to visit the United States while pregnant, but authorities said the businesses touted the benefits of having U.S. citizen babies and had women hide their pregnancies while seeking travel visas and lie about their planned trips. One business allegedly coached women to tell consular officials they planned to visit a Trump hotel in Hawaii, but in reality, they would spend three months at an apartment in Irvine, California to give birth.

U.S. authorities said the businesses not only engaged in fraud but have created a national security risk. Their customers—some who work for the Chinese government—have secured American citizenship for children who can later move back to the United States, and once they’re 21-years-old, sponsor their parents for green cards.

“I see this as a grave national security concern and vulnerability,” said Mark Zito, assistant special agent-in-charge of Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s homeland security investigations in Los Angeles. “Are some of them doing it for security because the United States is more stable? Absolutely. But will those governments take advantage of this? Yes, they will.”

The phenomenon of birth tourism is hardly new. The businesses have long operated in California and other states and cater to couples from China, Russia, Nigeria and elsewhere.

In the past, birth tourism operators sometimes ran into trouble with local code enforcement officials when neighbors in residential areas complained about crowding or excess trash, but they didn’t face federal scrutiny.

In 2015, federal agents raided roughly three dozen sites connected with birth tourism in Los Angeles, Orange and San Bernardino counties. More than 20 people were designated material witnesses to the cases but some later fled back to China and were charged with violating federal court orders, and an immigration lawyer who helped them leave the country was convicted of obstruction of justice.

 

Resident Jin-Jou Lu sits in his vehicle while talking to reporters outside after federal agents raided an upscale apartment complex where authorities say a birth tourism business charged pregnant women $50,000 for lodging, food and transportation, in Irvine, California, U.S. on March 3, 2015. (Jae C. Hong/AP)

This week, a federal grand jury indicted four people who were accused of running the three birth tourism businesses until the 2015 raids. One of the businesses dated at least to 2010 but advertised having brought 8,000 women to the United States—half of them from China—since it claimed to have been started in 1999.

Federal officials said each business brought hundreds of customers to give birth in the United States. In one of the cases, U.S. authorities outlined in court filings how wealthy Chinese couples paid the company You Win USA between $40,000 and $80,000 to travel to apartments in Irvine, California, to deliver their babies.

In one instance, a couple paid the indigent rate for hospital bills—a total of $4,080—even though they had more than $225,000 in a U.S. bank account they had used to shop at luxury stores including Louis Vuitton in Beverly Hills.

By Amy Taxin

RECOMMENDED
TOP VIDEOS