China Markets Feel the Pain of Stalled Derivatives Rollout

By Reuters
November 4, 2019 Updated: November 4, 2019

SHANGHAI/HONG KONG–A long list of stock and currency derivatives has been lying in wait for regulatory approval at the China Financial Futures Exchange (CFFEX), some for nearly a decade.

The exchange is hoping foreign asset managers will help vouch for these products and smooth the way forward for their eventual launch.

Zhang told his audience of mostly China-based executives of global money managers to speak up for the benefits of derivatives in investments, as “bad public perception makes it difficult for new products to be approved.”

Options, futures and other derivatives are in disrepute in China, particularly since 2015 when speculation in stock index futures was blamed for the violent market crash.

Unlike many other countries, China manages a highly centralized approval process for financial derivative launches, which explains why many products are stranded at CFFEX.

Delays in approvals are costing China. A dearth of tools for managing risk has become a major source of concern for global investors, even affecting the country’s inclusion in global indexes managed by the likes of MSCI and FTSE Russell.

It hinders Beijing’s efforts to attract foreign portfolio investment at a time when its long-running trade war with the United States has sapped export revenues.

Shanghai is losing market share in derivatives to other financial centers such as Singapore and Hong Kong, where rival exchanges that are subject to less government interference are rushing in with China-related products.

Liu Wencai, a former CFFEX official who helped design China’s index futures, seeks reform in the way exchange products are vetted for approval.

“As foreign money rapidly flows into China’s capital markets, our exchanges need to accelerate the rollout of financial futures and options,” said Liu, who founded risk-management consultancy D-Union after quitting CFFEX in 2015, when index futures were nearly killed by regulators.

Liu feels index futures were made the scapegoat in a politically-charged blame game during that crisis, and suggests the decision to launch new products be left to exchanges, rather than the securities regulator and the State Council.

China’s securities regulator and CFFEX did not return emailed requests for comment.

Badly Needed

At present, only six financial products—three stock index futures contracts and three bond futures contracts—trade on the 13-year-old CFFEX.

The list of products CFFEX has developed include futures based on the MSCI China A-share index and small-cap indexes such as ChiNext, sources with knowledge of the situation told Reuters.

Also being tested are 30-year bond futures, short-term interest rate futures and forex derivatives including dollar-yuan futures.

Foreign investors say they desperately need such tools to manage China risks.

MSCI, which added Chinese A shares into its emerging markets benchmark in 2018, decided in March to quadruple China’s inclusion factor to 20 percent—a process that will be completed later this month.

But any proposal by MSCI to increase that ratio further may be denounced by global investors who fret over the lack of efficient hedging tools in China, said Wei Zhen, head of China Research at MSCI, who predicted huge appetite for MSCI China A index futures.

The limited access to derivatives also contributed to FTSE Russell deciding not to add China to its widely-tracked government bond index in September.

“If I want to be able to trade interest rates and manage my exposure, I need to be able to trade China government bond futures,” said David Campbell, head of fixed income at lobby group ASIFMA. “And right now, that’s not available to the vast majority of foreign investors investing in China.”

While efforts to launch derivatives stall on the Chinese mainland, overseas exchanges are competing to offer derivative products to fill the vacuum.

The Singapore Exchange (SGX) is aggressively promoting an “all-China envelope” of risk management tools that include MSCI China futures, USD/CNH futures and iron ore futures and options.

Greater participation outside Asia pushed trading volumes in SGX’s listed yuan futures to record highs this year.

The Hong Kong stock exchange has also seen rapid growth in yuan futures trading and is planning new products, including MSCI China A-share index futures.

By Samuel Shen and Alun John