Senator Says Awaiting Response From Australia’s Foreign Affairs Department on Independent Tribunal Report Confirming Forced Organ Harvesting in China

By Henry Jom
Henry Jom
Henry Jom
Henry Jom is an Australian based reporter covering local Australia news. Contact him at
November 24, 2019 Updated: November 24, 2019

Australian Senator Eric Abetz has called on the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) to respond to the verdict handed down by an independent China Tribunal that found beyond reasonable doubt that the Chinese regime is practicing forced organ harvesting on its own citizens.

Abetz, a Liberal who holds a senate seat for Tasmania, told ABC radio on Nov. 19 that he has been advised by DFAT that it is currently in the process of reviewing the China Tribunal’s final report and that he is looking forward to receiving the department’s response.

“Clearly, these issues are on the government’s radar and our foreign minister, Marise Payne, has a very good track record being concerned about all matters concerning human rights,” Abetz said.

The independent tribunal, which was chaired by Sir Geoffrey Nice QC, concluded that forced organ harvesting has certainly been committed against Falun Gong practitioners in China. Falun Gong, a spiritual discipline consisting of meditation exercises and moral teachings based on truthfulness, compassion, and tolerance, has been brutally persecuted by the Chinese regime for the past two decades. Adherents of the practice have been thrown into prisons, labor camps, and brainwashing centers where many have been tortured in an effort to force them to renounce their faith.

The tribunal’s findings also reported a “risk” that Uyghurs in Xinjiang could be subject to forced organ harvesting while detained inside the widely reported “re-education camps” set up by Chinese authorities.

Nice said the tribunal reached these conclusions after considering all the evidence available to it, including testimony from more than 50 witnesses given at two hearings. Nice previously led the prosecution of former Yugoslavian President Slobodan Milosevic at the International Criminal Tribunal. Joining him on the panel were six international experts in the areas of law, transplant surgery, international politics, Chinese history, and business. China was also invited to present evidence to the tribunal but it declined.

“I’ve no reason to doubt that the whole of the report is in fact true and correct,” Abetz said. “I believe that the Australian government, and the international community, needs to take a very strong stance and tell the Chinese authorities that what they are undertaking is illegal, it’s barbaric—it’s a breach of every fundamental human right that you can think of.”

According to the tribunal findings, a conservative estimate of 60,000 to 90,000 transplant operations are conducted in Chinese hospitals each year—vastly greater than the figures suggested by the Chinese regime of 10,000 to 20,000 per year.

Epoch Times Photo
Doctors carrying organs for transplant surgery at a hospital in Henan Province on Aug. 16, 2012.(Screenshot/

Matthew Robertson, a doctoral student at the Australian National University (ANU), recently published in the peer-reviewed journal BMC Medical Ethics on Nov. 14 that “Beijing’s reported organ donation numbers don’t stack up and there is highly compelling evidence that they are being falsified.”

“It is difficult to imagine how this model could have been arrived at by mere chance, raising the distinct possibility that it was intended to deceive,” Robertson said in a press release. Robertson was formerly an editor at The Epoch Times.

Study co-author Jacob Lavee, professor of surgery at Tel Aviv University, told The Epoch Times via email that by applying statistical forensics on official Chinese donation datasets, the study found that the figures conform almost precisely to a mathematical formula—a quadratic function.

Senator Abetz said that human rights abuses against Falun Gong practitioners in China is indicative of genocide and extends to other religious groups in China.

“[T]he simple fact is that the evidence is there—that the Falun Gong seems to be the main target, that Buddhists, Uyghurs, House Christians, and indeed criminals, have all been targeted for organ harvesting. It is a barbaric trade, it should be condemned,” he said.

China Human Rights Partnerships Canned

In August, DFAT quietly suspended a two-decade-long human rights partnership with China over Beijing’s mass detention of ethnic Uyghurs.

The program was set up between DFAT, the Australian Human Rights Commission, and the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs to advance human rights reform under the Communist party.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison told radio FiveAA that the program “wasn’t getting the job done.”

Meanwhile, two Australian politicians—West Australia MP Andrew Hastie and Victorian Senator James Paterson, both from the Liberal Party—were denied entry into Beijing to attend a three-day study trip.

Hastie has spoken out against CCP influence in Australia and drew criticism in August from the Chinese regime when he compared the West’s response to China’s rise to France’s failure to contain the advance of Nazi Germany.

Paterson has spoken out about foreign influence risks at Australian universities and the escalating violence in Hong Kong. He said he will continue to do so.

“If that’s the price for speaking out, for being honest with our constituents about our concerns about our relationship with China, then that’s the price that I’m sure Andrew is willing to pay, and I’m willing to pay,” he told the ABC.

Epoch Times reporters Cathy He, Frank Fang, Mimi Nguyen-Ly, and Australian Associated Press contributed to this report.

Henry Jom
Henry Jom is an Australian based reporter covering local Australia news. Contact him at