The Best Mechanical Pencils

February 29, 2024

Updated:

May 01, 2024

Save

0:00

Have you ever felt lost trying to find the best mechanical pencils? You look through the options, can’t tell the difference, and then pick one based on its appearance. Choosing the right mechanical pencil is not as simple as some think. Many factors are at play, and they all differ in priority for each person.

Some value pencils with supreme build quality, while others sacrifice that for high-end features. One uses thin graphite for accurate lines, while the other needs thicker leads for natural shading. Whatever your reason is, it is best to learn more about how mechanical pencils work first.

This article goes over the most popular options, helping you find the most suitable mechanical pencil. By reading this article, you will learn about the nuances of each product. Keep on reading if you want to make the most informed decision and buy the perfect pencil for yourself.

The Breakdown:

Blick Premier Mechanical Pencil

The Blick Premier mechanical pencil sacrifices fanciness for build quality and general-use performance. The aluminum body makes you forget that the pencil shares the same price as a Starbucks white chocolate mocha! And the metal look gives it a majestic silver shine.

The Blick Premier is a bit heavy, which may exhaust your hands after an hour of consistent use. However, the pencil is comfortable to hold due to its slim size. Looks and feels aside, who is the best audience for this pencil?

This product comes with two HB leads and has a knurled grip. In simpler words, the pencil has two black leads inside it and a body that is easy to grab for sweaty hands. And this is perfect for the general audience.

The HB marking on the pencil indicates it is designed for general use. But you can easily refill it with leads of different hardness. Doing so is especially useful for creating accurate shadings and gradients or clean and sharp lines.

Pros:

Made in Japan with a full metal body, the Blick Premier feels hefty and durable. It feels more substantial and satisfying to hold than plastic alternatives.
This pencil is reasonably priced, making it an excellent value for a metal mechanical pencil.
Protects the lead and pocket from accidental damage.
The knurled grip provides some texture for better control, although it is not as pronounced as other options.
Allows for precise lead extension control with two separate clicks: one to release the sleeve and advance the lead, and another to retract the sleeve.
Available in 0.5mm and 0.7mm lead sizes to suit different writing styles.

Cons:

Only available with one grip texture, which might not suit everyone
Some may find the clicker mechanism requires too much force, especially for those with limited hand strength.
The lead reservoir is not as large as some other pencils, meaning more frequent lead refills are needed.

$10 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Uni Kuru Toga Pipe Slide Mechanical Pencil

Were you ever frustrated by a mechanical pencil’s broken lead ruining your journal entry? If yes, you may want to learn more about the Uni Kuru Toga Pipe Slide mechanical pencil.

This pencil is all about innovation. Thanks to its pipe slide system, the lead sleeve retracts a bit every time you press down while writing. This system protects the graphite core from snapping. And it is particularly beneficial with softer leads, as they break more often.

But the protective measures don’t stop at the pipe slide. Uni took an extra step by implementing a mechanism called lead rotation. As the name suggests, the lead rotates every time you lift the pencil from the page. This mechanism ensures you always use the sharp side of the graphite, preventing lead breaks.

The most compelling aspect of this mechanical pencil is its value for the price. It is feature-rich but affordable. Of course, this did not happen without any trade-offs. While the Kuru Toga Pipe Slide is well-made, it may not have the sleek, premium look that some prefer.

Pros:

The lead rotation mechanism ensures a sharp tip for cleaner writing.
The pipe slide system protects the lead from breaking under pressure and is suitable for heavy-handed writers.
Consistent lead sharpness allows for a thinner line, improving writing legibility and aesthetics.
The ridged grip provides comfort and control during writing.

Cons:

The lead rotation mechanism might wear out over time, potentially affecting its effectiveness.
The automatic lead rotation might not be ideal if you prefer a specific lead angle or write with a very light touch. It is also only available in 0.5mm lead size.
The product may not look as premium and aesthetically pleasing as some users like.

$6.84 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Bic Xtra-Smooth Mechanical Pencils

Bic’s Xtra-Smooth mechanical pencils deliver core, reliable functionality at a great price. These pencils are sold in packs of 40, while the alternatives charge more for one. There are two different variations available: the bright edition and the original edition.

The bright edition is for those who love collecting colorful stationery. This model offers a pack of vibrant barrel colors that give writing a touch of fun and personality. But for those interested in minimal looks, the original edition is more suitable. This package’s pencil barrels are all transparent and have a classic vibe.

No matter the edition, all the pencils in both packages have decent build quality. With a 0.7mm lead size, they are great options for smooth, consistently dark writing. From taking tests to jotting down notes, Bic’s Xtra-Smooth pencils will not disappoint.

But that is not all. These mechanical pencils also come with built-in erasers and a pocket clip. The erasers are impressive for a built-in eraser. And thanks to the sturdy pocket clip, you always have a pencil ready for use.

Now, what about the grip? Bic made the Xtra-Smooth pack with textured grips to ensure the pencil won’t tire the hand over time. This texture guarantees the product is comfortable even during heavy use. So, these pencils are suitable for everyone, especially those who tend to write for a long time.

Pros:

The 0.7mm lead suits all kinds of tasks and makes writing smooth and consistent.
Eliminates the need for sharpening and ensures a continuously-sharp point.
The built-in eraser effectively removes mistakes without smudging.
The textured grip reduces hand fatigue during extended writing sessions.
Allows easy attachment to pockets, notebooks, or bags for convenient carrying.
Available in transparent and vibrant barrel colors to suit individual preferences.

Cons:

Pre-filled leads will deplete over time and need refills.
While functional, the eraser quality might not suit everyone, especially for detailed erasing.
While affordable, the plastic body might be less durable than its metal-built alternatives.
The 0.7mm lead might be bulky for intricate drawings or precise writing.

$15.99 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Pentel Sharp Kerry Mechanical Pencil

The Sharp Kerry mechanical pencil is more on the premium side. With its minimal design, the pencil appeals to those who love classic stationery. It has a glossy black body with silver touches that complete the look. And what’s more, it is handcrafted, giving it a sense of accuracy and precision.

Now, what about Sharp Kerry’s durability? Other pencils may have a pocket clip. But Pentel Sharp Kerry features a removable clipped cap. It protects the writing point from falling and ensures you have your pencil when needed. Plus, since the Sharp Kerry is made of metal, it is more durable than plastic alternatives.

The pencil is also suitable as a gift. It comes in transparent packaging that complements its minimal design. With its comfortable grip, the pencil assures a smooth writing experience. And being handcrafted adds even more value to its premium look and feel.

When it comes to the build quality, it is not just about the metal shell. The internal components are also built to last a long time. But that is not all. The pencil features a refillable eraser. So you don’t need to worry about the built-in eraser wearing down.

Pentel offers Sharp Kerry in various colors and lead sizes, including 0.5mm and 0.7mm. And while the price isn’t low, it is reasonable for what Pentel Sharp Kerry has to offer.

Pros:

Protects pockets and bags from lead damage and prevents accidental poking.
Consistent lead advance even when capped.
Stays firmly in place while writing.
Smooth barrel with no sharp edges.
Hidden under the cap but easily accessible.

Cons:

May be difficult to find for users unfamiliar with the design.
Requires pulling the cap to advance lead, which can be confusing.
May not be suitable for users who prefer longer pencils.
Can lead to accidental lead breakage when posting the cap.
Compared to other automatic pencils.

$16 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Nicpro 6PCS Art Mechanical Pencils Set

What sets the Nicpro art set apart is the variety of items. The package has six mechanical pencils: three 2.0mm, one 0.5mm, one 0.7mm, and one 0.9mm. But the pencils are just the beginning. In this package, you will also receive nine replaceable pencil erasers and three regular ones.

Additionally, you will get 12 refill tubes with the set. These tubes include a pair of 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm refill tubes for their respective mechanical pencils. For the 2.0mm pencils, you will receive two 2H, two HB, and two 2B refill tubes.

The quality of all the pencils is decent when it comes to the material. Not only do all have a metal body, but they also use different textures to make an easy-to-hold grip. The thinner lead pencils feature rhombus rubber grips, while the 2mm ones have knurled grips for better control.

2.0mm pencils are mainly for shading, layering, and creating texture. For even higher customization, Nicpro added two sharpeners to the package. And what’s more, the 2.0mm pencils have built-in sharpeners in their caps. Overall, the variety of items in this set shows off the value for the money.

Pros:

Offers a variety of lead sizes (0.5mm, 0.7mm, 0.9mm, 2mm) and hardness (2B, HB, 2H) for different drawing and writing needs, from fine details to bold lines and shading.
Metal mechanical pencils often provide a comfortable weight balance and grip for extended use.
Includes multiple pencils, lead refills, erasers, and a case for a complete drawing or writing kit.
The compact size and case make it easy to take with you on the go.

Cons:

Adapting to different lead sizes and hardness levels may require some practice.
The pencil set is not available in a wide range of colors.
Some may not require all the items in the set but still have to pay for everything.

$18.99 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Rotring 600 Mechanical Pencil

Do you know what happens when you mix copper and zinc? These questions still send shivers down the spines of those who had to suffer through chemistry classes at school. But for Rotring, that very same combination led to a brilliant idea.

They created a “brass mechanism” for lead advancement using an alloy of copper and zinc. This mix has excellent anti-friction properties, creating a metal cushion for the leads. Thanks to this mechanism, you don’t need to worry about wasted, broken pencil leads.

The Rotring 600 has an elegant, professional feel to it. With its metal hexagonal barrel, the user can put the pencil wherever knowing that it won’t accidentally roll off the table. What’s more, the knurled, metal grip ensures you won’t experience hand fatigue, even during heavy use.

Rotring 600 also offers a hardness-grade indicator. Every time you change to a new lead, you can adjust this indicator to show its hardness degree. It is indispensable for those who regularly switch between leads of varying hardness degrees.

The pencil is available in 0.5mm and 0.7mm and is on the more expensive side. However, the brass mechanism and the premium build quality make it worth the price. For anyone not on a budget looking for a sturdy and polished pencil, the Rotring 600 is a reasonable option.

Pros:

The Rotring 600 features a fully metal body that feels sturdy and durable. The knurled grip is both comfortable and secure, even during extended use.
The brass mechanism ensures consistent lead advancement, while the fixed lead guidance sleeve minimizes lead breakage. It also makes it easier to see the paper.
The hexagonal barrel prevents the pencil from rolling, and the knurled grip provides a comfortable hold, even during long writing sessions.
Rotring 600 has a simple and minimal design that takes the two Ps (that is, premium and professional)
With its exceptional build quality, the Rotring 600 is designed to last a lifetime, making it a worthwhile investment if you prize quality.

Cons:

The Rotring 600 is pricier than other mechanical pencils. This can be a deciding factor for those on a budget.
While the knurled grip is comfortable for many, some users may find it too aggressive or unsuitable for their preferred grip style.
The metal body, while durable, can be prone to scratches and dents if not handled delicately. The lead sleeve may also bend if not protected, especially when carrying it around.

$31.77 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Uniball Kuru Toga Elite Mechanical Pencil

The Uniball Kuro Toga Elite mechanical pencil doesn’t excel in any specific area. Why? Because it doesn’t need to! This product is the ultimate example of a mechanical pencil middle ground. This set offers the Kuru Toga Elite mechanical pencil, 60 lead refills with HB hardness degree, and five pencil eraser refills.

The lead refills in this package do one thing differently than other lead brands. And that is infusing actual diamonds into the lead! By mixing nano-diamonds into the graphite, the leads gain extra strength and can help with smoother writing. The lead will also be less likely to smudge the paper.

The Kuru Toga Elite’s most significant selling point is its unique lead rotation mechanism. It ensures you always use the lead’s sharper side by rotating the lead the moment you lift the pencil. Moreover, the knurled grip makes the rounded barrel easier to hold during extended use.

The use of metal accents in this pencil is clever. It helps the pencil look fancy, even though it is not entirely made of metal. Kuro Toga Elite is also available in black and white, making it suitable for minimal design fans. And it is reasonably priced for a pencil with something to say in areas that matter.

Pros:

Not having the absolute best mechanisms or build quality helped the brand sacrifice nothing for lowering the price. All the needed features are there.
As you write, the lead rotates incrementally, preventing a single side from getting flat.
Because the lead wears evenly, the Kuru Toga dramatically reduces breakage. This quality is ideal for heavy-handed writers and those who prefer finer lead sizes.
The Elite model features metal accents with a comfortable, weighted feel in the hand.
The included lead and eraser refills provide plenty of supplies to get you going, making it a reasonable purchase.

Cons:

Not having the best mechanisms or build quality makes it unsuitable for those with specific needs and priorities.
If the unique rotation mechanism isn’t a major draw, you may want to look at other alternatives.
Some find the subtle clicking noise of the lead rotation mechanism slightly distracting.

$14.52 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Bic Velocity Strong Lead Mechanical Pencil

Bic Velocity Strong Lead mechanical pencils are part of a package suitable for educational purposes. It features four pencils in one set with five refillable erasers. And you won’t need to worry about refills, as the set comes with 12 extra HB leads.

The pencils in this package have a 0.9mm lead size. While the width is unsuitable for drawing precise lines, it is perfect for multiple-choice tests. But that’s not the only positive. The Bic Velocity Strong Lead pencil is also suitable for taking fast notes thanks to its thicker lead size.

What’s more, the mechanical pencil comes with built-in erasers and also has decent lead refill quality. So they are reliable options whenever you must jot something down. While not as effective as other alternatives, the cushioned grip adds to the comfort further.

The pencils have plastic barrels in 4 vibrant colors. While lightweight, the plastic material may not satisfy those looking for the best build quality. But it should not affect a student’s decision if they are looking for a cost-effective pencil to handle their everyday needs.

Pros:

The 0.9mm lead size is excellent for drawing, taking tests, and filling out forms.
The pencils in the set are fun and easy to identify.
The eraser is convenient for making corrections.
The pricing is fair for an everyday general-use mechanical pencil.

Cons:

May not be suitable for detailed work.
The plastic barrel lacks the premium and heavy feel of other alternatives.
While not expensive, you may find better value for the money if you are looking for specific features.

$5.98 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Four Candies Cute Mechanical Pencil Set

Four Candies Cute mechanical pencils are part of a pastel set that is quite versatile. It includes six mechanical pencils, six pencil lead refills, nine cap eraser refills, and three standalone erasers. All items are in colors that complement each other.

To ensure you don’t run out of leads any time soon, this set provides 360 of them! They are half 0.5mm, half 0.7mm, part resin, and part graphite. The use of resin instead of clay is a clever choice. It results in firmer, smoother, and break-resistant leads with less smudging.

While the pencil’s triangular shape helps avoid slipping, the Four Candies Cute set may lack a proper grip. However, their lightweight plastic body somewhat compensates for this issue. That being said, the lack of a textured grip may be a concern for some, especially during prolonged use.

The build quality of the Four Candies mechanical pencils may not be suitable for fans of heavy, metal writing tools. However, for those who value versatility, these pencils offer both 0.5mm and 0.7mm lead options. This proves helpful for both delicate artwork and everyday writing tasks.

Pros:

The pencils come in cute pastel colors that complement each other.
There are 360 lead refills in the set, which is a good value for the price.
The 0.5mm and 0.7mm lead sizes introduce a variety that is helpful for most writing tasks.
Having three jelly erasers and nine cap eraser refills adds to the set’s value.

Cons:

The pencils are made of plastic and may not be as durable as other alternatives.
The pencils may not last long if used every day, especially by children.
Not having a proper grip can cause the pencils to slip through the hands and be uncomfortable for prolonged use.

$15.99 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Zebra Pen M-701 Mechanical Pencil

Sturdy and strong, the Zebra M-701 mechanical pencil is suitable for everyday, heavy use. It features a stainless steel barrel, a clip, and a knurled grip. This combination ensures the perfect pencil for those looking for a product that not only looks premium but feels it, too. The steel is also easy to sanitize.

As for the use cases, the pencil has a 0.7mm lead size. It makes the pencil the perfect option for general and everyday use. But if you need a pencil that excels in a specific use case, you may need to check some alternatives.

Pros:

Compared to other metal mechanical pencils, it’s relatively inexpensive.
The metal body has good build quality.
A knurled grip provides a comfortable hold.
Includes a pocket clip and refillable eraser.

Cons:

Lacks some features found in premium pencils, like lead advance mechanisms.
Only accepts 0.7mm lead, which might not suit everyone’s needs.

$9.69 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Parker Jotter Mechanical Pencil

The Parker Jotter mechanical pencil has an understated elegance to it. The pencil’s minimal design is also suitable for a professional work environment. As a finishing touch, the cap has a delicately printed silver arrowhead that completes the overall look.

Fans of metal pencils would enjoy the stainless steel barrel. It is silver, simple, and has a majestic glow. And with the high-shine trim accenting the barrel, the pencil is cut out for those interested in stylish stationery.

Durability, simplicity, and a metal barrel are all characteristics of a decent gift pencil. But what’s more, is that the pencil comes in a sleek gift box as well. It is suitable for the workplace and formal situations.

What’s more, the Parker Jotter pencil comes with a retractable 0.5mm lead. So, it can handle most everyday writing tasks with ease. But you may need to look elsewhere if you prioritize perfectly natural shades.

Pros:

Stainless steel construction resists wear and tear.
The pencil fits well in most hands.
0.5mm lead is ideal for detailed writing and drawing thin lines.
Classic, minimal, professional design.
The click mechanism protects the lead and pocket.

Cons:

Compared to other mechanical pencils, it can be more expensive.
Only available in 0.5mm size, not ideal for creating shades.
Some may find the click mechanism distracting.

$24.99 at Amazon (Price at Time of Publishing)

Mechanical Pencils’ Reviews

Here are some reviews of popular mechanical pens on Amazon written by real people. These comments highlight both the positive and negative aspects of each pencil. Let’s see what people think.