Is Boy His Own Grandfather? (+Video)
Is Boy His Own Grandfather? (+Video)

In Beyond Science, Epoch Times explores research and accounts related to phenomena and theories that challenge our current knowledge. We delve into ideas that stimulate the imagination and open up new possibilities. Share your thoughts with us on these sometimes controversial topics in the comments section below.

A little boy referred to in case studies as “Sam,” showed convincing evidence that he is the reincarnation of his grandfather. Sam was 18 months old when his father was changing his diaper. Sam told his father, “When I was your age, I used to change your diaper.”

Dr. Jim B. Tucker at the Psychiatric Department of the University of Virginia explained Sam’s story in a video posted on the university website. Tucker has explored 2,500 cases of children remembering their past lives.

He explained that Sam made some startling statements while looking at an old photo album.


Sam was 4 years old when his grandmother died. His father brought an old photo album home from her house when he cleaned it out. To Sam’s parents’ knowledge, Sam had never seen a photo of his grandfather.

When they were looking through the album, Sam pointed to a photo of a car, and said “That’s my car.” It was his grandfather’s first car, one he’d been quite attached to.

Sam’s mother was skeptical—not predisposed to believe in reincarnation as a Baptist.

She tested him. She showed him a photo of his grandfather as a young boy with other boys of the same age. Sam pointed to his grandfather and said, “There I am.”

She corrected him and said, that’s your grandfather. “No, that’s me,” he replied.

Tucker said he looked at the photos and he would not have been able to tell which of the boys in the photo was the grandfather having seen other photos of the grandfather.

Testing it further, Sam’s mother asked if he remembered anything else from his past life. He said someone “turned my sister into a fish.”

“Who?” Sam’s mother asked. “Bad men.”

The grandfather’s sister had been murdered and her corpse was dumped in a body of water. Sam’s father said the boy would not have heard this story.

Dr. Michael Shermer, publisher of Skeptic Magazine, asked in the video: “How do we know these things actually happened?”

He said Sam’s case and the thousands of similar cases are based on anecdotes told by the parents, and events can sometimes become distorted when told by an excited parent. Also, parents may influence the children in various ways.

Tucker took parental enthusiasm into account, however. He recorded the initial attitude of parents and found no correlation between that attitude and what the children reported.

Some children have given detailed reports of the locations they lived in previous lives. Visiting the sites, researchers have verified that people had recently died in the areas and that those people’s lives fit the descriptions given by the children.

RELATED: 10 Amazing Things Kids Have Said About Past Lives

RELATED: Are Birthmarks Connected to Violent Death in Past Life?

*Image of boy looking through album via Shutterstock. 

  • Dean Webster

    Dr. Michael Shermer, and people like him, have a whole lot of evolving to do.

  • Godthes Upreme Being

    Everything is cyclic……everything!

  • Guest

    “Sam was 4 years old when his grandmother died.”
    So how can it be a case of reincarnation? The boy was born before the grandfather died. Something related to genetic memory, perhaps?

    • Ben_Chasteen

      Sam was 4 years old when his GRANMOTHER died not Grandfather.

      • Abby

        Whoops, sorry… that was so silly of me… :-)

        • Ben_Chasteen

          No problem, when I first read it I had to re-read it again to make sure

    • Hannah

      GrandMOTHER , not father lol……….

  • Luo

    Whenever there is a TV programme of this kind, there is a token materialist skeptic, “to provide balance”. Shermer did the deed this time. But when there is a programme presenting the standard materialist skeptic viewpoint, there is nobody on hand to provide balance for that.
    We are being programmed to become materialist skeptics.

× close