Subscribe

Struggling to Care For Our Broken LA Veterans

By Robin Kemker
Epoch Times Staff
Created: February 13, 2013 Last Updated: February 14, 2013
Related articles: United States » West
Print E-mail to a friend Give feedback

Three Old Veterans Guard members protest conditions at the Los Angeles National Veterans Home campus on the corner of Wilshire and San Vicente in West Los Angeles on Jan. 13, 2013. (L-R) Bob Rosebrock, 70; Larry Kegel, 74; and David Bischoff, 66, all served in the Army during the Vietnam War. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

Three Old Veterans Guard members protest conditions at the Los Angeles National Veterans Home campus on the corner of Wilshire and San Vicente in West Los Angeles on Jan. 13, 2013. (L-R) Bob Rosebrock, 70; Larry Kegel, 74; and David Bischoff, 66, all served in the Army during the Vietnam War. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

LOS ANGELES—Americans have always taken care of their war veterans. As early as 1636, the Plymouth Colony in Massachusetts passed a law stipulating that the colony would support soldiers who became disabled during the American Indian Wars.

With the Revolutionary War of 1776, Congress encouraged enlistments into the voluntary army by providing pensions if soldiers became disabled. The individual states and their communities were responsible for disabled veterans’ medical care.

After the Civil War, various states built veterans homes for the ongoing care of their disabled veterans and their families. This health care was later extended to all veterans through these state veterans homes, regardless of whether or not the illness or injury was caused while in military service, and the care encompassed indigent veterans without cost.

In 1888, Congress passed a bill that required states to set aside land to establish veterans homes to care for their disabled Civil War veterans and thereafter. One of these sites included 600 acres donated from two local landowners for the Los Angeles National Veterans Home, also called the VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System (GLA). 

The GLA West Los Angeles Medical Center campus now encompasses slightly over 400 acres after the construction of I-405 and other roads and federal buildings.

Several nonveteran commercial entities have leased land from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) on the L.A. veterans home site. 

“Today, there’s a public dog park, public community park, public golf course, two public theaters, and other gross misuse of this sacred land, including a state-of-the-art collegiate baseball diamond occupied by UCLA and oil extraction taking place on this site,” said Robert Rosebrock, a veterans’ advocate with the Old Veterans Guard and critic of local VA policy.

Rosebrock has been protesting the violations of the Land Grant Deed of 1888 regarding the Los Angeles National Veterans Home every Sunday afternoon since March 2008, along with other concerned veterans, on the corner of Wilshire and San Vicente, bordering the facility. 

Rosebrock and others approached the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) regarding this issue, and the organization took the case based on the deed’s language. The deed states, no less than five different times, that the land is “to locate, establish, construct, and permanently maintain a branch of said National Home for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers.”

A federal judge dismissed two of the legal claims, and just one remains—a claim that challenges the legality of the land leases on the property.

10 Years Later: Additional Federal VA Beds Are Coming

At the Jan. 25 groundbreaking of the first federally sponsored VA rehabilitation building in at least 10 years, Los Angeles County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky made his position well understood at the podium, saying, “This has been a long, long time in coming.” 

He is pleased that something is now happening at the veterans home to support L.A.’s disabled veterans.

Typical housing structure of many of the disabled veterans at the Los Angeles National Veterans Home campus on Feb. 5, 2013. These units, built 60 years ago, are the same style as Building 209, which is being rehabilitated and brought up to current building and seismic codes. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

Typical housing structure of many of the disabled veterans at the Los Angeles National Veterans Home campus on Feb. 5, 2013. These units, built 60 years ago, are the same style as Building 209, which is being rehabilitated and brought up to current building and seismic codes. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

Joan M. Mooney, assistant secretary for Congressional and Legislative Affairs for the VA, described the broad support that has developed over the past decade to assist the housing of homeless veterans. 

The Department of Housing and Urban Development in particular has been a key player in providing homeless housing vouchers to help chronically homeless veterans obtain permanent housing. Various housing authorities and state agencies are assisting in this effort. Other long-term private care facilities are also contracted to support the veterans.

L.A. City Councilman Bill Rosendahl addressed the topic of male combat veterans of war who suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), a common combat-related mental illness that is treated at the L.A. facility. “We do not know how to fully deal with it,” said Rosendahl.

Rosendahl then announced with loud applause from the audience, “Females can now be combat soldiers.”

According to data from the National Association of Social Workers (NASW) report, “Veterans Affairs Current Trends—About Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and Brain Injury in Iraq’s War Veterans,” enlisted soldiers have a 38 percent PTSD rate, Marines have a 31 percent PTSD rate, and National Guard units have a 49 percent PTSD rate. The PTSD rate for females is expected to be twice the rate of males, based on civilian rate studies. 

The Other Side of the Coin

“I first wrote Secretary Shinseki four years ago when he first took over the VA and I’ve sent him repeated letters about the malfeasance and misappropriation of Veterans property,” said Rosebrock after the January groundbreaking event. “I’ve probably sent him over 50 letters and never received one response.” He also pointed out that numerous buildings on the site are empty—buildings that were previously used to treat and house disabled veterans.

“It has taken 10 years for the VA and our Congressional representatives to get a mere $20 million to fund the rehabilitation of a single building previously used for treating mentally ill veterans,” he said.

Former Army league ballpark, handed over to the University of California-Los Angeles (UCLA). Veterans can attend without charge, but may not use the ballpark. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

Former Army league ballpark, handed over to the University of California-Los Angeles (UCLA). Veterans can attend without charge, but may not use the ballpark. (Robin Kemker/The Epoch Times)

Rosebrock expressed concern because “this and other buildings here have a dark history of experimentation on our disabled veterans.” He wants to see a new building not affected by medical research on veterans for psychotropic drug testing, lobotomies, and other treatments.

Looking at rehabilitation costs for the West L.A. VA Building 209, $20 million for 55 rooms for 70–90 veterans calculates to a cost range of $220,000 to $285,700 per veteran, depending on the final occupancy. An official from the City of Los Angeles, who did not want to be identified, said, “They could almost buy a home for each veteran for that cost.”

“If our U.S. government can ‘nation build’ around the world after the devastation of war, then this same U.S. government can demolish these antiquated, asylum-looking structures and build a modern Veterans Home here in the land of the free,” wrote Rosebrock in a Veterans Today article.

Nation’s Largest Concentration of Homeless Veterans

The “2011 Greater Los Angeles Homeless Count (GLAHC) Report” revealed that the number of homeless veterans in January 2011 was 8,131, which is 18 percent of L.A.’s homeless population. This was a 3 percent increase from the prior 2009 biennial survey. Also noted was that 31 percent of homeless veterans were chronically homeless—up 19 percent from the previous 2009 report.

In general, the overall homeless count in Los Angeles has gone down by 3 percent. This may be attributable to an improving economy and employment for nondisabled veteran workers.

Hopes of fewer disabled veterans on the street may not be fulfilled. According to the NASW report, a totally different trend is reflected. “[For Vietnam veterans], homelessness is becoming a major problem. But unlike with Vietnam veterans, when the homelessness occurred after years of service, these returning soldiers who become homeless are doing so within a year or less. … Combat trauma is thought to be largely responsible for this problem.”

The 2013 biennial GLAHC again conducted its on-the-ground homeless census with 5,000 volunteers at the end of January. The new report is expected midyear.

The Epoch Times publishes in 35 countries and in 21 languages. Subscribe to our e-newsletter.



  • Robert Rosebrock

    On behalf of the Old Veterans Guard and the thousands of disabled homeless Veterans in Los Angeles, we would like to thank The Epoch Times and Robin Kemker this great coverage of our cause. We truly appreciate the initiative and thoroughness of Mr. Kemker in writing this article in such a well-read newspaper. Thanks we trust that you will investigate deeper as to the cause behind so many Veterans being homeless when they already have a legally deeded home that is to be permanently maintained in their behalf.


GET THE FREE DAILY E-NEWSLETTER


Selected Topics from The Epoch Times

Sequestration