Subscribe

Does Memory Reside Outside the Brain?

By Leonardo Vintini
Epoch Times Staff
Created: August 29, 2008 Last Updated: June 18, 2012
Related articles: Science » Beyond Science
Print E-mail to a friend Give feedback

While many believe that memory resides inside the brain, evidence suggests that our minds might actually exist within a morphogenic field. (Photos.com)

While many believe that memory resides inside the brain, evidence suggests that our minds might actually exist within a morphogenic field. (Photos.com)

After decades of investigation, scientists are still unable to explain why no part of the brain seems responsible for storing memories.

Most people assume that our memories must exist somewhere inside our heads. But try as they might, medical investigators have been unable to determine which cerebral region actually stores what we remember. Could it be that our memories actually dwell in a space outside our physical structure?

Biologist, author, and investigator Dr. Rupert Sheldrake notes that the search for the mind has gone in two opposite directions. While a majority of scientists have been searching inside the skull, he looks outside.

According to Sheldrake, author of numerous scientific books and articles, memory does not reside in any geographic region of the cerebrum, but instead in a kind of field surrounding and permeating the brain. Meanwhile, the brain itself acts as a “decoder” for the flux of information produced by the interaction of each person with their environment.

In his paper “Mind, Memory, and Archetype Morphic Resonance and the Collective Unconscious” published in the journal Psychological Perspectives, Sheldrake likens the brain to a TV set—drawing an analogy to explain how the mind and brain interact.

“If I damaged your TV set so that you were unable to receive certain channels, or if I made the TV set aphasic by destroying the part of it concerned with the production of sound so that you could still get the pictures but could not get the sound, this would not prove that the sound or the pictures were stored inside the TV set.

“It would merely show that I had affected the tuning system so you could not pick up the correct signal any longer. No more does memory loss due to brain damage prove that memory is stored inside the brain. In fact, most memory loss is temporary: amnesia following concussion, for example, is often temporary.

This recovery of memory is very difficult to explain in terms of conventional theories: if the memories have been destroyed because the memory tissue has been destroyed, they ought not to come back again; yet they often do,” he writes.

Sheldrake goes on to further refute the notion of memory being contained within the brain, referring to key experiments which he believes have been misinterpreted. These experiments have patients vividly recall scenes of their past when areas of their cerebrum were electrically stimulated.

While these researchers concluded that the stimulated areas must logically correspond to the contained memory, Sheldrake offers a different view as he revisits the television analogy:  “… if I stimulated the tuning circuit of your TV set and it jumped onto another channel, this wouldn’t prove the information was stored inside the tuning circuit,” he writes.

Continued on next page: Morphogenetic Fields …




  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tall-Desk/100001156758685 Tall Desk

    I have always thought that scientists have figured out everything !  What a dope have I been.

  • 12Gd34

    It’s hilarious that science has been trying to figure this out from an extremely limited intellectual perspective. What if all life on this planet was actually a holograph? What most people call outer space could actually be a meditation zone. But, I guess we’ll get into all that in a few hundred years.

  • justin shin

    a couple questions. 
    If it isn’t stored inside the brain, where is it stored? This “field” idea is less supported then the idea of a physical structure, and this person seems to be claiming memory is from some other dimension or just manifests from thin air.

    If memory is not stored inside the brain, how come if i drove a railroad spike in someones head, it could wipe out some memories while leaving others untouched? The TV analogy fails here, because if the brain is merely acting as a medium or an interpreter, you would not be able to target specific memories, because the article says that by damaging the brain, you would be damaging the interpretation rather than the memory itself.

    The experiment with the rats also has some problems. Sure, a rat might not be affected in its attempts to do a trick, but we know humans are very different. If I were to delete half of a humans brain, no matter what part, some functions would be much more affected then others, as a humans brain is more specified than a rats brain.

    And this “organ mind” thing is ridiculous. Say I have a liver and kidney transplant, would I suddenly lose some mental faculty or memory? Of course not. 

    Anyways, this proposal that memory lies somewhere outside the physical plane of existence is a worse explanation then the explanation it is trying to replace.

    • asha007

      Justin, how does a  magnet work?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ivan-Pentchoukov/100002377796360 Ivan Pentchoukov

    Awesome!

  • http://www.spiralyne.co.uk/ Spirulina

    Nice idea but it doesn’t make sense. In areas of high electro-magnetic distorsion people can still think, speak and remember. In these areas surely any magnetic waves around the head where memories are stored would be inaccessible.  

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1002922576 Suze Land

      Not true. The four forces of physics do not interfere with each other. The electromagnetic field does not effect the gravitational or the nuclear so why would it have to interfere with the subtle energy fields?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ter-Lawson/100002180043839 Ter Lawson

    We are all nothing more than energy so why wouldn’t whatever field of energy that holds us in our form be more than a bread wrapper? Interesting theory. It might also explain why there appears to be a group mind. 


   

GET THE FREE DAILY E-NEWSLETTER


Selected Topics from The Epoch Times

USA Science Engineering Festival