Advertisement

UBS, U.S. Settle Tax Evasion Case

Reuters Created: Aug 12, 2009 Last Updated: Aug 12, 2009
Print | E-mail to a friend | Give feedback
Related articles: United States > National News
UBS Chairman Kaspar Villiger said the bank was "grateful" Swiss and U.S. governments had resolved their differences over Switzerland's bank secrecy laws. (Sebastian Derungs/AFP/Getty Images)
MIAMI—UBS AG and the U.S. and Swiss governments have agreed to settle a dispute over whether the Swiss bank should be forced to disclose the names of 52,000 wealthy American clients suspected of tax evasion.

The parties have initialed agreements that will "take a little time to be signed in final form," Department of Justice lawyer Stuart Gibson told U.S. District Court Judge Alan Gold during a brief conference call on Wednesday.

Details were not disclosed, and the case is expected to be dismissed once a final agreement is in place. UBS and the government had reached a settlement in principle on July 31.

Lawyers involved in the case say the settlement could involve the disclosure to U.S. authorities of 3,000 to perhaps more than 10,000 names of American clients suspected of using offshore accounts to evade taxes. Authorities believe the 52,000 UBS clients may be hiding nearly $15 billion of assets.

Washington's case against UBS, the world's second-largest wealth manager, had strained relations between the United States and Switzerland because it challenged the latter's jealously guarded bank secrecy laws.

"This is definitely good news for UBS," said Milan Patel, a tax lawyer at Withers LLP in Geneva.

"However, this may mean that UBS could face a new legal battle in Switzerland if the account holders claim UBS violated Swiss bank secrecy laws by disclosing their names," Patel added. "Thus, UBS may have ended the U.S. legal battle only to start the Swiss legal battle."

In February, UBS agreed to pay $780 million to settle criminal charges in a similar dispute with the U.S. government. The bank agreed to hand over data on about 250 U.S. clients, and promised to close its offshore business to U.S. clients.

Overhang Lifted

UBS Chairman Kaspar Villiger said the bank was "grateful" that the two governments had resolved their differences in the latest case. The bank said it expected a final agreement "in the near future."

Doug Shulman, commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service, the U.S. tax collection agency, said the pact with Switzerland "protects the United States government's interests."

Both governments must now sign off on the settlement, the Swiss Justice Ministry said.

A settlement would eliminate one overhang for UBS, whose losses on toxic debt led to a 6 billion Swiss franc ($6.5 billion) injection from the Swiss government last year.

The Swiss government has said it would like to sell its 9 percent stake in the bank soon.

U.S. authorities had sought the names of UBS clients they believed had either inherited substantial wealth and have European roots, are frequent business travelers who receive offshore compensation via Swiss accounts, or intended their accounts from the start as a means to avoid U.S. taxes.

But UBS, backed by the Swiss government, held onto the names, calling the U.S. demand a fishing expedition that would breach bilateral tax agreements and Swiss bank secrecy laws, which have been eroding in recent years.

"It is not possible to say just how well the Swiss did in resisting full compliance," said Robert Katzberg, a New York white-collar criminal lawyer at Kaplan & Katzberg who represents some U.S. taxpayers in the UBS matter.

He said he expected the United States to "receive much of what it has been seeking."

Others May Seek Amnesty

Alfred Mettler, a finance professor at Georgia State University and member of a Swiss task force on bank secrecy, said it would likely take months to implement a settlement, and may foreshadow an IRS push to ferret out suspected tax cheats.

"The IRS will certainly increase its efforts to go after non-taxed money wherever it is," he said. "But you need some evidence, and my guess is other banks, not only Swiss banks, must have taken steps to be proactive."

Details of the UBS agreement may affect the pace of activity under an IRS amnesty program that lets Americans reveal secret Swiss bank accounts in exchange for lower penalties. That program ends on Sept. 23.

"The store is still open for voluntary disclosure," said William Sharp, a principal at Sharp & Associates PA in Tampa, Florida who represents some UBS clients.

UBS shares rose 3.1 percent to 16.34 Swiss francs in Wednesday trading in Switzerland. In the United States, they were up 3.5 percent at $15.23 in afternoon trading on the New York Stock Exchange.

The case is U.S. v. UBS AG, U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida (Miami), No. 09-20423.



 
Advertisement