Ten Sentenced for Keeping Chinese Petitioners in Black Jails

By Jack Phillips
Epoch Times Staff
Created: February 7, 2013 Last Updated: February 8, 2013
Related articles: China » Democracy & Human Rights
Print E-mail to a friend Give feedback

Policemen sit in front of the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. (Ed Jones/AFP/Getty Images)

Policemen sit in front of the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. (Ed Jones/AFP/Getty Images)

A Chinese court has sentenced ten operators of “black jails”–secret detention centers for petitioners, who often face torture and other abuses while there–to prison terms ranging from six months to two years. The sentence is also a tacit admission to the existence of such facilities, something the regime has consistently denied. 

The Beijing court charged Wang Gaowei, the main defendant in the case, for renting two yards in Beijing’s Chaoyang district and hiring several roughs to detain petitioners from Henan Province who were airing their grievances in the Chinese capital about various issues they face in their home province, state-run media reported. These “black jails,” which achieved notoriety in China, are used to temporarily hold petitioners in Beijing before they are sent back home. 

In an incident in February 2012, four people who were jailed in Wang’s facility were injured before going back to Henan, according to the state-run China Daily. They came back two months later and reported their detention to police, who then raided Wang’s center and arrested him.

Helping to incentivize the black jail system is the fact that Chinese Communist Party officials are penalized via a point system when a petitioner from their region makes it to the central appeals office in Beijing, according to the China Daily.

In these usually run-down facilities, petitioners face torture, rape, beatings, and even death.

Petitioners involved in Wang’s case were angry at the Beijing court’s sentencing because local officials, who they believed were responsible for their detention, were not implicated in any of the crimes.

“The verdict said they had nothing to do with the local government, how can this be?” said Jia Qiuxia, a petitioner, according to the South China Morning Post.

Four of the victims were given around 2,400 yuan ($385) in compensation, but said that this was not enough to cover their injuries or mental suffering sustained from being beaten by guards. Jia said that despite the defendants’ sentencing, she thinks that “black jails” will persist around China. “We still hear about other people being taken away,” she told the paper. 

Nicholas Bequelin of Human Rights Watch said that the sentences will send a message to other local Communist Party officials who might be thinking about intercepting petitioners in Beijing. But he said that punishing the hired thugs responsible for setting up the jails does not solve the root problem.

“Beijing will continue to look the other way as long as petitioners are seen as disturbing the image of the capital,” Bequelin told the Morning Post. 

Hong Kong-based human rights researcher Joshua Rosenzweig told The Associated Press that the case is “certainly significant, but it’s also probably the tip of the iceberg.”  

It remains to be seen if the Chinese regime will continue to pursue similar cases against “black jail” operators, Rosenzweig said, or if this week’s sentencing was just a once-off.

Hu Jun, who has petitioned in China for 17 years, told The Epoch Times that the kidnapping of petitioners is usually conducted by the individuals tied to the Communist Party’s “stability maintenance” (weiwen) apparatus, with assistance from local neighborhood committees and police departments.

The weiwen machine is overseen by the Political and Legislative Affairs Committee (PLAC), a high-level Party organ that controls all security forces in China.

An insider in Beijing recently told New Epoch Weekly, a news magazine published in Hong Kong and the United States, that former high ranking officials in the PLAC recently submitted a report saying that 453 security officials have been put under shuanggui, a secretive Party process of interrogation and detention, in the past three months—most from the public security sector. Additionally, 12 high ranking PLAC officials have committed suicide. Shuanggui is usually implemented against officials who have “violated discipline,” including engaging in corruption or disobeying important Party edicts.

Prominent rights attorney, Pu Zhiqiang posted onto his various microblog accounts on Feb. 6, in response to the news: “I say that the former Minister of Public Security, the former head of PLAC and now our elderly comrade, Zhou Yongkang, is destroying our nation and ruining our people. If we want to step out of the shadow of maintaining stability, Zhou’s social stability maintenance system must be held accountable. Too many tragedies are directly related to Zhou Yongkang. Zhou stayed in power for ten years. He is indeed poisoning the society and killing our people.”

Xie Jiyou, an analyst of Beijing’s political machinations, told The Epoch Times that the high-profile coverage of this news by Xinhua indicates that Xi Jinping, in preparation to halting China’s re-education through labor camps, has gone one step further in striking at Zhou and the PLAC’s “stability maintenance” system.

The Epoch Times publishes in 35 countries and in 21 languages. Subscribe to our e-newsletter.


Selected Topics from The Epoch Times

Claire Suarez