Analysis of Biden-Xi Phone Call: Key Concerns and Bargaining Chips Between the US and China

Analysis of Biden-Xi Phone Call: Key Concerns and Bargaining Chips Between the US and China
President Joe Biden speaks in the Indian Treaty Room of the White House, on April 3, 2024. (Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images)
4/8/2024
Updated:
4/8/2024
0:00
News Analysis 

On April 2, President Joe Biden and Chinese leader Xi Jinping suddenly held a 105-minute phone conversation where both sides elaborated on their respective positions on longstanding issues such as Taiwan, the South China Sea, North Korea, trade, etc. Analysts have noticed subtle bargaining in each side’s official statements.

Xi displayed a noticeably softer tone than before as he emphasized trust and stability in bilateral relations. Chinese independent TV producer Li Jun said on NTD’s Chinese-languaged program “Pinnacle View” that previously, the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) attitude was more confrontational. However, now Xi is leaning towards reconciliation and improving relations with the United States, aiming to avoid conflicts.

On the U.S. side, President Biden first warned China against interfering in U.S. elections, and he expressed concern that China is supporting Russia in the Russia-Ukraine War and helped Russia rebuild military-industrial bases, posing a long-term threat to the security of Europe. Furthermore, regarding Taiwan, President Biden expressed hope for peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait and signaled China not to attempt to change the status quo.

US-China Geopolitical Struggles

Henry Wu, a Taiwanese macroeconomics scholar and chief economist at AIA Capital, said on “Pinnacle View” that high-level meetings between the United States and China usually involve a detailed preliminary procedure, including video calls and conferences. However, this call between Xi and President Biden was sudden and rushed, without any prior contact. He believes that Xi likely requested the call.

Mr. Wu pointed out that Taiwan is indeed a focus of the conversation since Taiwan’s newly elected President, Lai Ching-te, will be inaugurated on May 20, and the United States wanted China not to cause trouble at this time. Nevertheless, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) views Taiwan as a part of China that needs to be reclaimed, and the political symbol of the Republic of China needs to be eliminated. In other words, the existence of Taiwan, or its official name, the Republic of China, challenges the CCP’s legitimacy, and its freedom and democracy exist in stark contrast with the CCP.

According to Mr. Wu, another focus was the Philippines. The CCP faces significant domestic crises and needs to shift focus. Military conflicts abroad may be viewed as necessary by the CCP. Currently, China is ramping up its provocations at the disputed Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea, stirring up conflicts with the Philippines. The United States emphasized the South China Sea issue precisely for this reason.

Mr. Wu explained, “Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. said that if China continues to interfere with our resupply of the Second Thomas Shoal, we will counterattack. The Philippines had not had this attitude before. After the Philippines took a tough stance, the United States surprisingly backed up the Philippines. I feel the United States hopes that if there is an armed conflict, let it happen in the South China Sea rather than the Taiwan Strait, essentially the United States may be indirectly protecting Taiwan using the Philippines.”

Upgraded Sanctions Against China

Guo Jun, editor-in-chief of The Epoch Times’ Hong Kong edition, said on the “Pinnacle View” that in this call, the most concerning topic for the CCP is AI chips and the restrictions the United States imposes on China’s tech. In its briefing, the CCP claimed that the United States has been constantly suppressing China’s economic and technological development, and the list of sanctions against Chinese companies is getting longer. The CCP said it will not sit by idly as the United States attempts to deprive China of its right to development.

Ms. Guo said that a few days before the call between the two leaders on March 29, the United States revised its policy aimed at preventing China from acquiring U.S.-made AI chips and semiconductor manufacturing tools. This includes completely banning the sale of the most advanced AI chips designed by companies like Nvidia to China, as well as any equipment for manufacturing these chips.

“Recently, there was also news that at the world’s most influential AI conference, the Nvidia GTC, held in Silicon Valley with over 900 summit sessions and over 200 participating companies, a big shot from China’s private equity sector also attended the conference,” she said. “He stated that his deepest impression of the conference was that nobody discussed China. China has been a hot topic and focus in recent years, but the country was completely ignored at this event. Whether it’s the development of AI in China or investment, hardly anyone cares about China. He believes that this change points towards the trend that the United States will completely isolate China in AI development.”

Ms. Guo pointed out that although China is now a major power in AI development, China has a flaw, which is that it cannot produce advanced AI chips. If China is excluded from AI development, five years from now, many industries in China will be in trouble, and this is the most important issue for the CCP.

“So, during this call between Xi Jinping and Mr. Biden, Xi Jinping’s strongest point is that he will not sit idly by,” she said. “So I believe the chip issue is the most worrying thing for China.”

Michael Zhuang contributed to this report.
“Pinnacle View,” a joint venture by NTD and The Epoch Times, is a high-end TV forum centered around China. The program gathers experts from around the globe to dissect pressing issues, analyze trends, and offer profound insights into societal affairs and historical truths.